Antifungal Susceptibilities of Candida Species Causing Vulvovaginitis and Epidemiology of Recurrent Cases
http://www.100md.com
微生物临床杂志 2005年第5期
Department of Pathology
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, Iowa
ABSTRACT
There are limited data regarding the antifungal susceptibility of yeast causing vulvovaginal candidiasis, since cultures are rarely performed. Susceptibility testing was performed on vaginal yeast isolates collected from January 1998 to March 2001 from 429 patients with suspected vulvovaginal candidiasis. The charts of 84 patients with multiple positive cultures were reviewed. The 593 yeast isolates were Candida albicans (n = 420), Candida glabrata (n = 112), Candida parapsilosis (n = 30), Candida krusei (n = 12), Saccharomyces cerevisiae ( n = 9), Candida tropicalis (n = 8), Candida lusitaniae (n = 1), and Trichosporon sp. (n = 1). Multiple species suggesting mixed infection were isolated from 27 cultures. Resistance to fluconazole and flucytosine was observed infrequently (3.7% and 3.0%); 16.2% of isolates were resistant to itraconazole (MIC 1 μg/ml). The four imidazoles (econazole, clotrimazole, miconazole, and ketoconazole) were active: 94.3 to 98.5% were susceptible at 1 μg/ml. Among different species, elevated fluconazole MICs (16 μg/ml) were only observed in C. glabrata (15.2% resistant [R], 51.8% susceptible-dose dependent [S-DD]), C. parapsilosis (3.3% S-DD), S. cerevisiae (11.1% S-DD), and C. krusei (50% S-DD, 41.7% R, considered intrinsically fluconazole resistant). Resistance to itraconazole was observed among C. glabrata (74.1%), C. krusei (58.3%), S. cerevisiae (55.6%), and C. parapsilosis (3.4%). Among 84 patients with recurrent episodes, non-albicans species were more common (42% versus 20%). A 4-fold rise in fluconazole MIC was observed in only one patient with C. parapsilosis. These results support the use of azoles for empirical therapy of uncomplicated candidal vulvovaginitis. Recurrent episodes are more often caused by non-albicans species, for which azole agents are less likely to be effective.
INTRODUCTION
Limited data addressing the incidence of vulvovaginal candidiasis suggest approximately two-thirds of women experience at least one episode during their lifetime and nearly 50% of women have multiple episodes (3, 12). The majority of cases of vulvovaginal candidiasis are caused by Candida albicans; however, episodes due to non-albicans species of Candida appear to be increasing (15, 22, 29). Most non-albicans Candida species have higher azole MICs, and infections they cause are often difficult to treat (10, 20, 21, 26).
A possible explanation for more frequent isolation of non-albicans species from vulvovaginitis patients may be the increased use of topical azole agents—available as over-the-counter preparations in the United States since 1992 (14, 24). Patients who see a physician usually receive empirical therapy; vaginal cultures are not routinely obtained, and susceptibility testing is rarely performed.
Surveillance programs for candidemia have demonstrated that fluconazole resistance among C. albicans bloodstream isolates is rare (1%) (16). The majority of studies analyzing yeast isolates from vulvovaginitis patients have also shown the recovery of fluconazole-resistant C. albicans isolates to be an unusual event (1, 7, 10, 20, 27), but they often have included a small number of isolates. The increased use of over-the-counter antifungals and prolonged therapy for recurrent candidiasis are risk factors for the emergence of azole resistance among C. albicans isolated from vulvovaginitis patients.
The purpose of this study was to determine the species distribution and prevalence of antifungal resistance among a large collection of yeast isolates from patients with candidal vulvovaginitis. Retrospective chart review was performed on patients with multiple vaginal yeast isolates in order to examine the epidemiology of recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Vaginal yeast cultures (n = 564) were collected from 429 University of Iowa vulvovaginitis clinic patients with signs and symptoms suggestive of candidal vulvovaginitis from January 1998 to March 2001. The decision to submit a culture was made by the attending gynecologist, and only the identification of yeast isolated was reported. All specimens were plated on CHROMagar (Hardy Diagnostics, Santa Maria, CA) to ensure detection of mixed infections. Cultures were incubated for 72 h at 35°C in ambient air. Identification was based on colony morphology and carbohydrate assimilation using Vitek YBC cards (bioMerieux Vitek, Inc., Hazelwood, MO). If the identity of the yeast was uncertain, isolates were plated on cornmeal agar or sent to a reference laboratory. The isolates were banked in water at room temperature.
Susceptibility testing was performed on the banked isolates using a broth microdilution method according to NCCLS guidelines (13). Antifungals and concentrations tested were fluconazole (0.12 to 128 μg/ml), flucytosine (0.06 to 64 μg/ml), nystatin (0.06 to 64 μg/ml), and itraconazole, econazole, clotrimazole, miconazole, and ketoconazole (all 0.007 to 8 μg/ml). A 0.1-ml yeast inoculum of 1.5 (±1.0) x 103 cells/ml in RPMI 1640 medium was added to each microdilution well. The trays were incubated at 35°C for 46 to 50 h in ambient air. The MICs were read as the lowest antifungal concentration with substantially lower turbidity (50%) compared to growth in the antifungal-free growth control well for all agents except nystatin. Nystatin MICs were read as the minimal antifungal concentration with complete inhibition of growth. NCCLS interpretive criteria were applied for fluconazole, itraconazole, and flucytosine. There are no NCCLS breakpoints for the other antifungals tested. Quality control was ensured by testing the NCCLS-recommended quality control strains Candida parapsilosis ATCC 22019 and Candida krusei ATCC 6258.
Patients with multiple positive cultures during January 1998 to March 2001 were considered to have recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis. A retrospective chart review was performed on this subset of patients to collect epidemiologic data that included age, symptoms, comorbid conditions, and response to therapy. Correlation of MIC with response to antifungal therapy and change in MIC among successive same-species isolates therapy were also examined. The significance of group proportion differences was assessed with Fisher's exact test.
RESULTS
A total of 593 yeast isolates were obtained from 564 vaginal specimens: 420 C. albicans, 112 Candida glabrata, 30 C. parapsilosis, 12 C. krusei, 9 Saccharomyces cerevisiae, 8 Candida tropicalis, 1 Candida lusitaniae, and 1 Trichosporon sp. (Table 1). Of the 429 women with positive yeast cultures, 84 (19.6%) had multiple positive cultures (233 isolates) during the study period. Non-albicans species were more commonly isolated (P = 0.0001) from the cultures of patients with multiple positive cultures (42% of initial positive cultures) than from cultures of patients with a single positive culture (20% non-albicans). The predominant non-albicans species recovered was C. glabrata. The prevalence of C. glabrata noted among patients with multiple positive cultures was significantly higher than among patients with a single positive culture (29% versus 12%; P = 0.0002). The species distribution of isolates collected during the 39-month period was relatively stable over time (data not shown).
Mixed infection with multiple species of yeast isolated from one specimen was observed in 27 episodes of vulvovaginitis (4.8%). The majority of these mixed cultures (21 out of 27) yielded C. albicans and C. glabrata. Three cultures yielded C. albicans and C. krusei, and the remaining three mixed cultures yielded C. glabrata, C. tropicalis, and C. albicans; S. cerevisiae and C. glabrata; and C. parapsilosis and C. albicans. Thirteen of the 27 mixed cultures occurred in patients with only a single positive culture during the study period. The remaining 14 mixed cultures occurred in 10 of the 84 patients with multiple positive cultures whose charts were reviewed.
Positive cultures noted during chart review obtained before and after the January 1998 to March 20001 study period are included in Table 2 to present a more comprehensive picture of the pattern of yeast isolation for patients with recurrent vulvovaginitis. The cultures of 52 patients yielded the same species repeatedly, while multiple species (different species over time or multiple species from a single specimen) were isolated from the other 32 patients. The age of patients at their first vulvovaginitis clinic visit ranged from 18 to 78 years. Among 18 to 59 year olds, a single species (C. albicans) was the most common culture result (34 of 67 patients; 50.7%). The majority of patients age 60 or greater (70.6%) had cultures that yielded different species over time or multiple species from a single specimen.
Every patient with multiple yeast isolates reported at least one symptom consistent with, but not specific for, candidal vulvovaginitis. These symptoms included vulvovaginal itching, vulvovaginal burning, vulvovaginal pain, vaginal discharge, and dyspareunia.
Every patient with recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis had at least one of 40 medical conditions listed in Table 3 noted in their medical history or occurring while they were followed at the vulvovaginitis clinic. A large portion of the 84 patients (46.4%) had received recent antibiotic therapy. Many patients had lower genital tract conditions, including vulvar contact dermatitis (60.7%), vulvar vestibulitis (25%), vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia (23.8%), and lichen simplex chronicus (21.4%). Other predominant medical conditions noted among these patients were diabetes (15.5%), depression (10.7%), and postmenopausal symptoms treated with hormone replacement therapy (11.9%).
Susceptibility test results for the 593 isolates revealed that resistance to fluconazole (3.7%) or flucytosine (3.0%) was infrequent. Resistance to itraconazole occurred among 16.2% of the isolates. The imidazoles (econazole, clotrimazole, miconazole, and ketoconazole) were active against 94.3 to 98.5% of the isolates (MIC 1 μg/ml). Nystatin MICs ranged from 1 to 16 μg/ml, with a MIC inhibiting 90% of isolates (MIC90) of 4 μg/ml.
The susceptibility test results for each species are presented in Table 4. Fluconazole resistance (MIC 64 μg/ml) was observed only among C. glabrata isolates (15.2%) and C. krusei isolates (41.7%; all C. krusei isolates should be reported as fluconazole resistant per NCCLS guidelines). Fluconazole susceptible-dose dependent (MIC, 16 to 32 μg/ml) isolates were found among C. glabrata (51.8%), C. krusei (50%), S. cerevisiae (11.1%), and C. parapsilosis (3.3%). Itraconazole resistance was observed among C. glabrata (74.1%), C. parapsilosis (3.3%), C. krusei (58.3%), and S. cerevisiae (55.6%) isolates. Flucytosine resistance was noted among C. albicans (3.3%), C. krusei (8.3%), C. tropicalis (12.5%), C. lusitaniae (100%), and Trichosporon sp. (100%).
Response to antifungal therapy among patients with multiple positive cultures is compared to the MIC in Table 5. The most common antifungal prescribed was fluconazole, with a typical course of oral therapy 200 mg every other day for three doses. If C. glabrata was suspected, boric acid was prescribed (600-mg capsule inserted intravaginally once daily for 2 weeks). A few patients received intravaginal econazole or clotrimazole once or twice daily for 14 days. Data regarding compliance with prescribed therapy were not collected.
A majority (61.5%) of the patients with 78 evaluable episodes of C. albicans vulvovaginitis treated with fluconazole reported improvement in symptoms at the next clinic visit (Table 5). All of the C. albicans isolates were well below the fluconazole susceptibility breakpoint of 8 μg/ml, and there was no difference in outcome associated with the MIC. A minority of patients treated with fluconazole for all but one species of non-albicans vulvovaginitis reported improvement. The exception was two episodes of C. krusei vulvovaginitis with symptomatic improvement after fluconazole therapy despite MICs of 32 and 128 μg/ml.
Patients reported improvement for only 48.6% of the 70 evaluable episodes of C. glabrata vulvovaginitis treated with boric acid therapy. There was no attempt to measure in vitro boric acid activity in this study, since there are no standardized methods for testing this agent.
Four of the 7 evaluable episodes (57.1%) treated with clotrimazole and 4 of 10 vulvovaginitis episodes treated with econazole were associated with clinical improvement. All of the isolates treated with clotrimazole or econazole had MICs generally considered susceptible (1 μg/ml).
The MICs of isolates (same species) from patients with multiple positive cultures were relatively stable. A fourfold or greater rise in fluconazole, econazole, or clotrimazole MIC within a species was observed in only two patients (Table 6). The fluconazole MIC of C. parapsilosis isolates from one patient increased sixfold (0.5 μg/ml to 32 μg/ml) after three courses of fluconazole. The econazole MICs for successive C. glabrata isolates increased fourfold in a second patient, but there was no record of the patient receiving this antifungal. There were five instances of a threefold MIC increase without evidence the patients had received the antifungal.
DISCUSSION
In this study, C. albicans was the most common species associated with vulvovaginitis (76%), followed by C. glabrata (16%). The overall percentage of non-albicans vaginitis (24%) was higher than in two previous reports (9, 29). Spinillo et al. reported 17% of 209 isolates from symptomatic patients referred to an Italian vulvovaginitis clinic were non-albicans species in 1995 (29). An Australian study found vulvovaginal yeast carriage among 21% of 5,802 women receiving a pelvic exam in a primary care setting; non-albicans species were isolated in only 11% of the positive cultures (9). This difference likely reflects a bias towards more complicated patients in the current study who are symptomatic and had prior episodes before being referred to a vulvovaginitis clinic. Nyirjesy et al. (15) reported a higher rate of non-albicans species than the current study: 32% of 77 isolates from 74 patients with chronic vulvovaginitis.
The subset of isolates from patients with multiple positive cultures during the study period included a higher percentage of non-albicans species (42%) than the isolates from patients with only one positive culture (20% non-albicans). The marked difference in species distribution between these two groups may be the result of a higher level of antifungal exposure among patients with multiple positive cultures providing selective pressure for non-albicans species that are more likely to be azole resistant. An alternative explanation is that patients who develop vulvovaginitis from a non-albicans species are more likely to fail therapy and have multiple positive cultures.
The prevalence of C. albicans noted among the subset of patients with multiple positive cultures in the current study (58%) was similar to the prevalence of C. albicans reported by Candida bloodstream infection surveillance studies (52 to 56%) (18). The prevalence of C. glabrata (29%) among patients with multiple positive vaginal cultures was higher than that reported among bloodstream isolates (8 to 18%) (18).
The fluconazole susceptibility of all 420 C. albicans vaginal isolates in the current study is consistent with other reports. A recent U.S. study found no fluconazole resistance among 401 C. albicans isolates recovered from women with recurrent vulvovaginitis (27). In an earlier U.S. study, all 100 C. albicans isolates from vulvovaginitis clinic patients were also fluconazole susceptible (10). No fluconazole resistance was identified among 75 C. albicans vaginal isolates from symptomatic women in England (7). A study in Brazil reported no fluconazole resistance among 56 C. albicans vaginal isolates (12 isolates were from asymptomatic women, suggesting colonization rather than infection) (20). An Italian study with only 19 C. albicans vaginal isolates (13 from asymptomatic women) reported no fluconazole resistance (1).
There was only one case report of a fluconazole-resistant (MIC, 64 μg/ml) C. albicans vaginal isolate causing vulvovaginitis (collected in 1995) until recently (25). A fluconazole-resistant C. albicans isolate from a vulvovaginitis patient in the United Kingdom was reported in 2002 (6). A U.S. study reported fluconazole resistance in 14 of 393 (3.6%) C. albicans isolates collected from complicated vaginitis patients prior to 2001 (28). In New York, 2 of 93 (2.1%) C. albicans vaginal isolates from 1999 were fluconazole resistant—only 1 was from a symptomatic patient (11). A 2002 Belgium study found an astonishing 21% of 84 vaginal C. albicans isolates to have fluconazole MICs of 64 μg/ml by NCCLS methods, but the 8 fluconazole-resistant isolates that were available for retesting were susceptible by the EUCAST method (2). This illustrates the difficulty that can be encountered in interpreting the trailing growth of static azole agents and the importance of sending isolates with unexpected susceptibility test results to established reference laboratories for retesting.
Previous studies correlating susceptibility test results of Candida species for azoles with clinical outcome support the "90-60 rule" established for bacterial infections: approximately 90% of infections due to susceptible isolates respond, while infections due to resistant isolates respond approximately 60% of the time (19). Demonstration of a correlation between clinical response and MIC in the current study was hindered by (i) the lack of in vitro azole resistance detected among the predominant organism isolated (C. albicans) and (ii) the small number of episodes due to non-albicans species treated with azoles (i.e., the most common non-albicans species, C. glabrata, was usually treated with boric acid). Among patients with multiple positive cultures, only 62% of the evaluable episodes of C. albicans vulvovaginitis treated with fluconazole showed clinical improvement at the next clinic visit—a lower response rate than predicted by the 90-60 rule.
As expected, higher azole MICs were found among non-albicans Candida species. A larger portion of the C. glabrata vaginal isolates in the current study was fluconazole nonsusceptible (67% [51.8% susceptible-dose dependent, 15.2% resistant]) than has been reported for bloodstream infection isolates (43% [36% susceptible-dose dependent, 7% resistant]) (17). These in vitro results support the use of alternative agents when treating vulvovaginitis caused by non-albicans species (especially C. glabrata or C. krusei).
Among patients with recurrent positive cultures, 34 of 70 evaluable episodes of C. glabrata vulvovaginitis treated with boric acid (49%) were reported as improved at the next clinic visit. A higher 81% clinical improvement rate was noted in a retrospective study of 26 episodes of C. glabrata vulvovaginitis treated with boric acid (22). Another retrospective study of boric acid therapy reported successful outcome for 64% of 73 patients in Michigan and 71% of 38 patients in Israel with C. glabrata vulvovaginitis (23). There are case reports of boric acid poisoning associated with accidental ingestion and open wound absorption, but a 1974 study found no detectable levels of boric acid in the serum of 20 women after 2 weeks of therapy (600-mg capsule inserted intravaginally twice daily) (30). A lower daily dose of boric acid (600 mg once daily for 2 weeks) was prescribed to patients in the current study and is recommended by other studies (22, 23). There is a recent report of successful therapy with topical flucytosine among 90% of 27 women with C. glabrata vulvovaginitis who had failed azole and boric acid therapy (23). The in vitro activity of flucytosine was superior to all other agents tested against C. glabrata in the current study.
There are few studies reporting in vitro susceptibility data using the NCCLS method for the polyene nystatin. Carrillo-Munoz reported the nystatin MIC90 values for 55 C. albicans and 11 C. glabrata clinical isolates as 2 μg/ml and 4 μg/ml, respectively (5). The nystatin MICs for 589 oral yeast isolates from South African human immunodeficiency virus patients and healthy individuals ranged from 2 to 16 μg/ml with an MIC90 of 8 μg/ml for 466 C. albicans isolates (4). These values are similar to the nystatin MIC90 of 4 μg/ml for the isolates tested in the current study. The clustering of nystatin MICs at 2 to 4 μg/ml and the use of other agents to treat patients prevent any meaningful interpretation of the nystatin in vitro results in this study.
In view of the overall high level of susceptibility to antifungals, the small number of patients with substantial increases in antifungal MICs (Table 6) was not surprising. The highest rise in fluconazole MIC (from 0.5 μg/ml to 32 μg/ml after three courses of fluconazole over a 7-month period) occurred in a middle-aged woman with a history of chronic sinusitis, urinary tract infections, and vaginal yeast infections who was referred to an immunologist for further evaluation. She had low-titer antibody responses to pneumococcal and tetanus vaccines, but normal immunoglobulin G levels. Every vaginal culture collected from this patient during the study period yielded C. parapsilosis. In addition to fluconazole, therapy included boric acid, nystatin, econazole, itraconazole, gentian violet, topical amphotericin B, and topical flucytosine. This patient was still symptomatic with yeast seen on wet mount 3 years after her first vulvovaginitis clinic visit and is an unfortunate example of the difficult challenge treatment of these patients may present.
The conclusions that can be drawn from the epidemiologic data from the current study are limited because of the retrospective collection of information and the lack of a control group. Fidel and Sobel presented a complex model for the immunopathogenesis of recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis and concluded recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis is not caused by impaired systemic cell-mediated immunity, but they postulated a host defect in local vaginal mucosa immunity (8). Factors known to impact the vaginal environment and contribute to vulvovaginal candidiasis (antibiotic therapy, diabetes, and hormone therapy) were present in a minority of the patients with multiple positive cultures in the current study, and only two patients had an immunodeficiency diagnosis. A notable portion of patients in the current study had multiple yeast species isolated from a single culture and changes in species isolated over time. The paucity of predisposing conditions, the diversity among infecting yeast, and the predominance of antifungal-susceptible C. albicans isolates support a host defect in vaginal mucosal immunity as a key factor in the pathogenesis of recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis. However, the increased prevalence of non-albicans species (42%) with higher azole MICs among patients with multiple positive cultures in the current study suggests antifungal resistance may also be an important factor for some patients.
The high frequency with which C. albicans was recovered in this study and its azole susceptibility support the continued use of azole agents for empirical therapy of uncomplicated candidal vulvovaginitis. Cultures from patients with recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis should be obtained to detect non-albicans species that are less likely to respond to an azole agent. Prospective studies with control groups are needed to determine the optimal therapy for candidal vulvovaginitis caused by non-albicans species.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank Holly Huynh and Linda Boyken for assistance with susceptibility testing and Lena Jaspering for assistance with medical record acquisition.
Financial support for this study was provided by Pfizer Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
M.A.P. and D.J.D. have received research funding from Pfizer, Schering, Vicuron, and Fujisawa. M.A.P. and D.J.D. are members of the speakers' bureau for Pfizer and Merck. S.S.R. has received research funding from Pfizer. For all other authors, there is no conflict.
REFERENCES
Arzeni, D., M. Del Poeta, O. Simonnetti, A. M. Offidani, L. Lamura, M. Balducci, N. Cester, A. Giacometti, and G. Scalise. 1997. Prevalence and antifungal susceptibility of vaginal yeasts in outpatients attending a gynecological center in Ancona, Italy. Eur. J. Epidemiol. 13:447-450.
Bauters, T. G. M., M. A. Dhont, M. I. Temmerman, and H. J. Nelis. 2002. Prevalence of vulvovaginal candidiasis and susceptibility to fluconazole in women. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 187:569-574.
Berg, A. O., F. E. Heidrich, S. D. Fihn, J. J. Bergman, R. W. Wood, W. E. Stamm, and K. K. Holmes. 1984. Establishing the cause of genitourinary symptoms in women in a family practice: comparison of clinical examination and comprehensive microbiology. JAMA 251:620-625.
Blignaut, E., S. Messer, R. J. Hollis, and M. A. Pfaller. 2002. Antifungal susceptibility of South African oral yeast isolates from HIV/AIDS patients and healthy individuals. Diagn. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 44:169-174.
Carrillo-Munoz, A. J., G. Quindos, C. Tur, M. T. Ruesga, Y. Miranda, O. del Valle, P. A. Cossum, and T. L. Wallace. 1999. In-vitro antifungal activity of liposomal nystatin in comparison with nystatin, amphotericin B cholesteryl sulphate, liposomal amphotericin B, amphotericin B lipid complex, amphotericin B desoxycholate, fluconazole, and itraconazole. J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 44:397-401.
Dorrell, L., and A. Edwards. 2002. Vulvovaginitis due to fluconazole resistant Candida albicans following self treatment with non-prescribed triazoles. Sex. Transm. Infect. 78:308.
El-Din, S. S., M. T. Reynolds, H. R. Ashbee, R. C. Barton, and E. G. V. Evans. 2001. An investigation into the pathogenesis of vulvovaginal candidosis. Sex. Transm. Infect. 77:179-183.
Fidel, P. L., and J. D. Sobel. 1996. Immunopathogenesis of recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis. Clin. Microbiol. Rev. 9:335-348.
Holland, J., M. L. Young, O. Lee, and C.-A. Chen. 2003. Vulvovaginal carriage of yeasts other than Candida albicans. Sex. Transm. Infect. 79:249.
Lynch, M. E., and J. D. Sobel. 1994. Comparative in vitro activity of antimycotic agents against pathogenic vaginal yeast isolates. J. Med. Vet. Mycol. 32:267-274.
Mathema, B., E. Cross, E. Dun, S. Park, J. Bedell, B. Slade, M. Williams, L. Riley, V. Chaturvedi, and D. S. Perlin. 2001. Prevalence of vaginal colonization by drug-resistant Candida species in college-age women with previous exposure to over-the-counter azole antifungals. Clin. Infect. Dis. 33:e23-e27.
McCormack, W. M., Jr., S. H. Zinner, and W. M. McCormack. 1994. The incidence of genitourinary infections in a cohort of healthy women. Sex. Transm. Dis. 21:63-64.
National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards. 2002. Reference method for broth dilution antifungal susceptibility testing for yeasts. Approved standard M27-A2, 2nd ed. National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards, Wayne, Pa.
Nyirjesy, P., M. V. Weitz, M. H. T. Grody, and B. Lorber. 1997. Over-the-counter and alternative medicines in the treatment of chronic vaginal symptoms. Obstet. Gynecol. 90:50-53.
Nyirjesy, P., S. M. Seeney, M. H. T. Grody, C. A. Jordan, and H. R. Buckley. 1995. Chronic fungal vaginitis: the value of cultures. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 173:820-823.
Pfaller, M. A., and D. J. Diekema. 2002. Role of sentinel surveillance of candidemia: trends in species distribution and antifungal susceptibility. J. Clin. Microbiol. 40:3551-3557.
Pfaller, M. A., D. J. Diekema, S. A. Messer, L. Boyken, and R. J. Hollis. 2003. Activities of fluconazole and voriconazole against 1,586 recent clinical isolates of Candida species determined by broth microdilution, disk diffusion, and Etest methods: report from the ARTEMIS global antifungal susceptibility program, 2001. J. Clin. Microbiol. 41:1440-1446.
Pfaller, M. A., S. A. Messer, R. J. Hollis, R. N. Jones, G. V. Doern, M. E. Brandt, and R. A. Hajjeh. 1999. Trends in species distribution and susceptibility to fluconazole among blood stream isolates of Candida species in the United States. Diagn. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 33:217-222.
Rex, J. H., and M. A. Pfaller. 2002. Has antifungal susceptibility testing come of age Clin. Infect. Dis. 35:982-989.
Ribeiro, M. A., R. Dietze, C. R. Paula, D. A. Da Matta, and A. L. Colombo. 2000. Susceptibility profile of vaginal yeast isolates from Brazil. Mycopathologia 151:5-10.
Singh, S., J. D. Sobel, P. Bhargava, D. Boikov, and J. A. Vazquez. 2002. Vaginitis due to Candida krusei: epidemiology, clinical aspects, and therapy. Clin. Infect. Dis. 35:1066-1070.
Sobel, J. D., and W. Chaim. 1997. Treatment of Torulopsis glabrata vaginitis: retrospective review of boric acid therapy. Clin. Infect. Dis. 24:649-652.
Sobel, J. D., W. Chaim, V. Nagappan, and D. Leaman. 2003. Treatment of vaginitis caused by Candida glabrata: use of topical boric acid and flucytosine. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 189:1297-1300.
Sobel, J. D., S. Faro, R. W. Force, B. Foxman, W. J. Ledger, P. R. Nyirjesy, B. D. Reed, and P. R. Summers. 1998. Vulvovaginal candidiasis: epidemiologic, diagnostic, and therapeutic considerations. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 178:203-211.
Sobel, J. D., and J. A. Vazquez. 1996. Symptomatic vulvovaginitis due to fluconazole-resistant Candida albicans in a female who was not infected with human immunodeficiency virus. Clin. Infect. Dis. 22:726-727.
Sobel, J. D., J. Vazquez, M. Lynch, C. Meriwether, and M. J. Zervos. 1993. Vaginitis due to Saccharomyces cerevisiae: epidemiology, clinical aspects, and therapy. Clin. Infect. Dis. 16:93-99.
Sobel, J. D., H. C. Wiesenfeld, M. Martens, P. Danna, T. M. Hooton, A. Rompalo, M. Sperling, C. Livengood III, B. Horowitz, J. V. Thron, L. Edwards, H. Panzer, and T.-C. Chu. 2004. Maintenance fluconazole therapy for recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis. N. Engl. J. Med. 351:876-883.
Sobel, J. D., M. Zervos, B. D. Reed, T. Hooton, D. Soper, P. Nyirjesy, M. W. Heine, J. Willems, and H. Panzer. 2003. Fluconazole susceptibility of vaginal isolates obtained from women with complicated Candida vaginitis: clinical implications. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 47:34-38.
Spinillo, A., E. Capuzzo, R. Gulminetti, P. Marone, L. Colonna, and G. Piazzi. 1997. Prevalence of and risk factors for fungal vaginitis caused by non-albicans species. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 176:138-141.
Swate, T. E., and J. C. Weed. 1974. Boric acid treatment of vulvovaginal candidiasis. Obstet. Gynecol. 43:893-895.(Sandra S. Richter, Rudolp)
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, Iowa
ABSTRACT
There are limited data regarding the antifungal susceptibility of yeast causing vulvovaginal candidiasis, since cultures are rarely performed. Susceptibility testing was performed on vaginal yeast isolates collected from January 1998 to March 2001 from 429 patients with suspected vulvovaginal candidiasis. The charts of 84 patients with multiple positive cultures were reviewed. The 593 yeast isolates were Candida albicans (n = 420), Candida glabrata (n = 112), Candida parapsilosis (n = 30), Candida krusei (n = 12), Saccharomyces cerevisiae ( n = 9), Candida tropicalis (n = 8), Candida lusitaniae (n = 1), and Trichosporon sp. (n = 1). Multiple species suggesting mixed infection were isolated from 27 cultures. Resistance to fluconazole and flucytosine was observed infrequently (3.7% and 3.0%); 16.2% of isolates were resistant to itraconazole (MIC 1 μg/ml). The four imidazoles (econazole, clotrimazole, miconazole, and ketoconazole) were active: 94.3 to 98.5% were susceptible at 1 μg/ml. Among different species, elevated fluconazole MICs (16 μg/ml) were only observed in C. glabrata (15.2% resistant [R], 51.8% susceptible-dose dependent [S-DD]), C. parapsilosis (3.3% S-DD), S. cerevisiae (11.1% S-DD), and C. krusei (50% S-DD, 41.7% R, considered intrinsically fluconazole resistant). Resistance to itraconazole was observed among C. glabrata (74.1%), C. krusei (58.3%), S. cerevisiae (55.6%), and C. parapsilosis (3.4%). Among 84 patients with recurrent episodes, non-albicans species were more common (42% versus 20%). A 4-fold rise in fluconazole MIC was observed in only one patient with C. parapsilosis. These results support the use of azoles for empirical therapy of uncomplicated candidal vulvovaginitis. Recurrent episodes are more often caused by non-albicans species, for which azole agents are less likely to be effective.
INTRODUCTION
Limited data addressing the incidence of vulvovaginal candidiasis suggest approximately two-thirds of women experience at least one episode during their lifetime and nearly 50% of women have multiple episodes (3, 12). The majority of cases of vulvovaginal candidiasis are caused by Candida albicans; however, episodes due to non-albicans species of Candida appear to be increasing (15, 22, 29). Most non-albicans Candida species have higher azole MICs, and infections they cause are often difficult to treat (10, 20, 21, 26).
A possible explanation for more frequent isolation of non-albicans species from vulvovaginitis patients may be the increased use of topical azole agents—available as over-the-counter preparations in the United States since 1992 (14, 24). Patients who see a physician usually receive empirical therapy; vaginal cultures are not routinely obtained, and susceptibility testing is rarely performed.
Surveillance programs for candidemia have demonstrated that fluconazole resistance among C. albicans bloodstream isolates is rare (1%) (16). The majority of studies analyzing yeast isolates from vulvovaginitis patients have also shown the recovery of fluconazole-resistant C. albicans isolates to be an unusual event (1, 7, 10, 20, 27), but they often have included a small number of isolates. The increased use of over-the-counter antifungals and prolonged therapy for recurrent candidiasis are risk factors for the emergence of azole resistance among C. albicans isolated from vulvovaginitis patients.
The purpose of this study was to determine the species distribution and prevalence of antifungal resistance among a large collection of yeast isolates from patients with candidal vulvovaginitis. Retrospective chart review was performed on patients with multiple vaginal yeast isolates in order to examine the epidemiology of recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Vaginal yeast cultures (n = 564) were collected from 429 University of Iowa vulvovaginitis clinic patients with signs and symptoms suggestive of candidal vulvovaginitis from January 1998 to March 2001. The decision to submit a culture was made by the attending gynecologist, and only the identification of yeast isolated was reported. All specimens were plated on CHROMagar (Hardy Diagnostics, Santa Maria, CA) to ensure detection of mixed infections. Cultures were incubated for 72 h at 35°C in ambient air. Identification was based on colony morphology and carbohydrate assimilation using Vitek YBC cards (bioMerieux Vitek, Inc., Hazelwood, MO). If the identity of the yeast was uncertain, isolates were plated on cornmeal agar or sent to a reference laboratory. The isolates were banked in water at room temperature.
Susceptibility testing was performed on the banked isolates using a broth microdilution method according to NCCLS guidelines (13). Antifungals and concentrations tested were fluconazole (0.12 to 128 μg/ml), flucytosine (0.06 to 64 μg/ml), nystatin (0.06 to 64 μg/ml), and itraconazole, econazole, clotrimazole, miconazole, and ketoconazole (all 0.007 to 8 μg/ml). A 0.1-ml yeast inoculum of 1.5 (±1.0) x 103 cells/ml in RPMI 1640 medium was added to each microdilution well. The trays were incubated at 35°C for 46 to 50 h in ambient air. The MICs were read as the lowest antifungal concentration with substantially lower turbidity (50%) compared to growth in the antifungal-free growth control well for all agents except nystatin. Nystatin MICs were read as the minimal antifungal concentration with complete inhibition of growth. NCCLS interpretive criteria were applied for fluconazole, itraconazole, and flucytosine. There are no NCCLS breakpoints for the other antifungals tested. Quality control was ensured by testing the NCCLS-recommended quality control strains Candida parapsilosis ATCC 22019 and Candida krusei ATCC 6258.
Patients with multiple positive cultures during January 1998 to March 2001 were considered to have recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis. A retrospective chart review was performed on this subset of patients to collect epidemiologic data that included age, symptoms, comorbid conditions, and response to therapy. Correlation of MIC with response to antifungal therapy and change in MIC among successive same-species isolates therapy were also examined. The significance of group proportion differences was assessed with Fisher's exact test.
RESULTS
A total of 593 yeast isolates were obtained from 564 vaginal specimens: 420 C. albicans, 112 Candida glabrata, 30 C. parapsilosis, 12 C. krusei, 9 Saccharomyces cerevisiae, 8 Candida tropicalis, 1 Candida lusitaniae, and 1 Trichosporon sp. (Table 1). Of the 429 women with positive yeast cultures, 84 (19.6%) had multiple positive cultures (233 isolates) during the study period. Non-albicans species were more commonly isolated (P = 0.0001) from the cultures of patients with multiple positive cultures (42% of initial positive cultures) than from cultures of patients with a single positive culture (20% non-albicans). The predominant non-albicans species recovered was C. glabrata. The prevalence of C. glabrata noted among patients with multiple positive cultures was significantly higher than among patients with a single positive culture (29% versus 12%; P = 0.0002). The species distribution of isolates collected during the 39-month period was relatively stable over time (data not shown).
Mixed infection with multiple species of yeast isolated from one specimen was observed in 27 episodes of vulvovaginitis (4.8%). The majority of these mixed cultures (21 out of 27) yielded C. albicans and C. glabrata. Three cultures yielded C. albicans and C. krusei, and the remaining three mixed cultures yielded C. glabrata, C. tropicalis, and C. albicans; S. cerevisiae and C. glabrata; and C. parapsilosis and C. albicans. Thirteen of the 27 mixed cultures occurred in patients with only a single positive culture during the study period. The remaining 14 mixed cultures occurred in 10 of the 84 patients with multiple positive cultures whose charts were reviewed.
Positive cultures noted during chart review obtained before and after the January 1998 to March 20001 study period are included in Table 2 to present a more comprehensive picture of the pattern of yeast isolation for patients with recurrent vulvovaginitis. The cultures of 52 patients yielded the same species repeatedly, while multiple species (different species over time or multiple species from a single specimen) were isolated from the other 32 patients. The age of patients at their first vulvovaginitis clinic visit ranged from 18 to 78 years. Among 18 to 59 year olds, a single species (C. albicans) was the most common culture result (34 of 67 patients; 50.7%). The majority of patients age 60 or greater (70.6%) had cultures that yielded different species over time or multiple species from a single specimen.
Every patient with multiple yeast isolates reported at least one symptom consistent with, but not specific for, candidal vulvovaginitis. These symptoms included vulvovaginal itching, vulvovaginal burning, vulvovaginal pain, vaginal discharge, and dyspareunia.
Every patient with recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis had at least one of 40 medical conditions listed in Table 3 noted in their medical history or occurring while they were followed at the vulvovaginitis clinic. A large portion of the 84 patients (46.4%) had received recent antibiotic therapy. Many patients had lower genital tract conditions, including vulvar contact dermatitis (60.7%), vulvar vestibulitis (25%), vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia (23.8%), and lichen simplex chronicus (21.4%). Other predominant medical conditions noted among these patients were diabetes (15.5%), depression (10.7%), and postmenopausal symptoms treated with hormone replacement therapy (11.9%).
Susceptibility test results for the 593 isolates revealed that resistance to fluconazole (3.7%) or flucytosine (3.0%) was infrequent. Resistance to itraconazole occurred among 16.2% of the isolates. The imidazoles (econazole, clotrimazole, miconazole, and ketoconazole) were active against 94.3 to 98.5% of the isolates (MIC 1 μg/ml). Nystatin MICs ranged from 1 to 16 μg/ml, with a MIC inhibiting 90% of isolates (MIC90) of 4 μg/ml.
The susceptibility test results for each species are presented in Table 4. Fluconazole resistance (MIC 64 μg/ml) was observed only among C. glabrata isolates (15.2%) and C. krusei isolates (41.7%; all C. krusei isolates should be reported as fluconazole resistant per NCCLS guidelines). Fluconazole susceptible-dose dependent (MIC, 16 to 32 μg/ml) isolates were found among C. glabrata (51.8%), C. krusei (50%), S. cerevisiae (11.1%), and C. parapsilosis (3.3%). Itraconazole resistance was observed among C. glabrata (74.1%), C. parapsilosis (3.3%), C. krusei (58.3%), and S. cerevisiae (55.6%) isolates. Flucytosine resistance was noted among C. albicans (3.3%), C. krusei (8.3%), C. tropicalis (12.5%), C. lusitaniae (100%), and Trichosporon sp. (100%).
Response to antifungal therapy among patients with multiple positive cultures is compared to the MIC in Table 5. The most common antifungal prescribed was fluconazole, with a typical course of oral therapy 200 mg every other day for three doses. If C. glabrata was suspected, boric acid was prescribed (600-mg capsule inserted intravaginally once daily for 2 weeks). A few patients received intravaginal econazole or clotrimazole once or twice daily for 14 days. Data regarding compliance with prescribed therapy were not collected.
A majority (61.5%) of the patients with 78 evaluable episodes of C. albicans vulvovaginitis treated with fluconazole reported improvement in symptoms at the next clinic visit (Table 5). All of the C. albicans isolates were well below the fluconazole susceptibility breakpoint of 8 μg/ml, and there was no difference in outcome associated with the MIC. A minority of patients treated with fluconazole for all but one species of non-albicans vulvovaginitis reported improvement. The exception was two episodes of C. krusei vulvovaginitis with symptomatic improvement after fluconazole therapy despite MICs of 32 and 128 μg/ml.
Patients reported improvement for only 48.6% of the 70 evaluable episodes of C. glabrata vulvovaginitis treated with boric acid therapy. There was no attempt to measure in vitro boric acid activity in this study, since there are no standardized methods for testing this agent.
Four of the 7 evaluable episodes (57.1%) treated with clotrimazole and 4 of 10 vulvovaginitis episodes treated with econazole were associated with clinical improvement. All of the isolates treated with clotrimazole or econazole had MICs generally considered susceptible (1 μg/ml).
The MICs of isolates (same species) from patients with multiple positive cultures were relatively stable. A fourfold or greater rise in fluconazole, econazole, or clotrimazole MIC within a species was observed in only two patients (Table 6). The fluconazole MIC of C. parapsilosis isolates from one patient increased sixfold (0.5 μg/ml to 32 μg/ml) after three courses of fluconazole. The econazole MICs for successive C. glabrata isolates increased fourfold in a second patient, but there was no record of the patient receiving this antifungal. There were five instances of a threefold MIC increase without evidence the patients had received the antifungal.
DISCUSSION
In this study, C. albicans was the most common species associated with vulvovaginitis (76%), followed by C. glabrata (16%). The overall percentage of non-albicans vaginitis (24%) was higher than in two previous reports (9, 29). Spinillo et al. reported 17% of 209 isolates from symptomatic patients referred to an Italian vulvovaginitis clinic were non-albicans species in 1995 (29). An Australian study found vulvovaginal yeast carriage among 21% of 5,802 women receiving a pelvic exam in a primary care setting; non-albicans species were isolated in only 11% of the positive cultures (9). This difference likely reflects a bias towards more complicated patients in the current study who are symptomatic and had prior episodes before being referred to a vulvovaginitis clinic. Nyirjesy et al. (15) reported a higher rate of non-albicans species than the current study: 32% of 77 isolates from 74 patients with chronic vulvovaginitis.
The subset of isolates from patients with multiple positive cultures during the study period included a higher percentage of non-albicans species (42%) than the isolates from patients with only one positive culture (20% non-albicans). The marked difference in species distribution between these two groups may be the result of a higher level of antifungal exposure among patients with multiple positive cultures providing selective pressure for non-albicans species that are more likely to be azole resistant. An alternative explanation is that patients who develop vulvovaginitis from a non-albicans species are more likely to fail therapy and have multiple positive cultures.
The prevalence of C. albicans noted among the subset of patients with multiple positive cultures in the current study (58%) was similar to the prevalence of C. albicans reported by Candida bloodstream infection surveillance studies (52 to 56%) (18). The prevalence of C. glabrata (29%) among patients with multiple positive vaginal cultures was higher than that reported among bloodstream isolates (8 to 18%) (18).
The fluconazole susceptibility of all 420 C. albicans vaginal isolates in the current study is consistent with other reports. A recent U.S. study found no fluconazole resistance among 401 C. albicans isolates recovered from women with recurrent vulvovaginitis (27). In an earlier U.S. study, all 100 C. albicans isolates from vulvovaginitis clinic patients were also fluconazole susceptible (10). No fluconazole resistance was identified among 75 C. albicans vaginal isolates from symptomatic women in England (7). A study in Brazil reported no fluconazole resistance among 56 C. albicans vaginal isolates (12 isolates were from asymptomatic women, suggesting colonization rather than infection) (20). An Italian study with only 19 C. albicans vaginal isolates (13 from asymptomatic women) reported no fluconazole resistance (1).
There was only one case report of a fluconazole-resistant (MIC, 64 μg/ml) C. albicans vaginal isolate causing vulvovaginitis (collected in 1995) until recently (25). A fluconazole-resistant C. albicans isolate from a vulvovaginitis patient in the United Kingdom was reported in 2002 (6). A U.S. study reported fluconazole resistance in 14 of 393 (3.6%) C. albicans isolates collected from complicated vaginitis patients prior to 2001 (28). In New York, 2 of 93 (2.1%) C. albicans vaginal isolates from 1999 were fluconazole resistant—only 1 was from a symptomatic patient (11). A 2002 Belgium study found an astonishing 21% of 84 vaginal C. albicans isolates to have fluconazole MICs of 64 μg/ml by NCCLS methods, but the 8 fluconazole-resistant isolates that were available for retesting were susceptible by the EUCAST method (2). This illustrates the difficulty that can be encountered in interpreting the trailing growth of static azole agents and the importance of sending isolates with unexpected susceptibility test results to established reference laboratories for retesting.
Previous studies correlating susceptibility test results of Candida species for azoles with clinical outcome support the "90-60 rule" established for bacterial infections: approximately 90% of infections due to susceptible isolates respond, while infections due to resistant isolates respond approximately 60% of the time (19). Demonstration of a correlation between clinical response and MIC in the current study was hindered by (i) the lack of in vitro azole resistance detected among the predominant organism isolated (C. albicans) and (ii) the small number of episodes due to non-albicans species treated with azoles (i.e., the most common non-albicans species, C. glabrata, was usually treated with boric acid). Among patients with multiple positive cultures, only 62% of the evaluable episodes of C. albicans vulvovaginitis treated with fluconazole showed clinical improvement at the next clinic visit—a lower response rate than predicted by the 90-60 rule.
As expected, higher azole MICs were found among non-albicans Candida species. A larger portion of the C. glabrata vaginal isolates in the current study was fluconazole nonsusceptible (67% [51.8% susceptible-dose dependent, 15.2% resistant]) than has been reported for bloodstream infection isolates (43% [36% susceptible-dose dependent, 7% resistant]) (17). These in vitro results support the use of alternative agents when treating vulvovaginitis caused by non-albicans species (especially C. glabrata or C. krusei).
Among patients with recurrent positive cultures, 34 of 70 evaluable episodes of C. glabrata vulvovaginitis treated with boric acid (49%) were reported as improved at the next clinic visit. A higher 81% clinical improvement rate was noted in a retrospective study of 26 episodes of C. glabrata vulvovaginitis treated with boric acid (22). Another retrospective study of boric acid therapy reported successful outcome for 64% of 73 patients in Michigan and 71% of 38 patients in Israel with C. glabrata vulvovaginitis (23). There are case reports of boric acid poisoning associated with accidental ingestion and open wound absorption, but a 1974 study found no detectable levels of boric acid in the serum of 20 women after 2 weeks of therapy (600-mg capsule inserted intravaginally twice daily) (30). A lower daily dose of boric acid (600 mg once daily for 2 weeks) was prescribed to patients in the current study and is recommended by other studies (22, 23). There is a recent report of successful therapy with topical flucytosine among 90% of 27 women with C. glabrata vulvovaginitis who had failed azole and boric acid therapy (23). The in vitro activity of flucytosine was superior to all other agents tested against C. glabrata in the current study.
There are few studies reporting in vitro susceptibility data using the NCCLS method for the polyene nystatin. Carrillo-Munoz reported the nystatin MIC90 values for 55 C. albicans and 11 C. glabrata clinical isolates as 2 μg/ml and 4 μg/ml, respectively (5). The nystatin MICs for 589 oral yeast isolates from South African human immunodeficiency virus patients and healthy individuals ranged from 2 to 16 μg/ml with an MIC90 of 8 μg/ml for 466 C. albicans isolates (4). These values are similar to the nystatin MIC90 of 4 μg/ml for the isolates tested in the current study. The clustering of nystatin MICs at 2 to 4 μg/ml and the use of other agents to treat patients prevent any meaningful interpretation of the nystatin in vitro results in this study.
In view of the overall high level of susceptibility to antifungals, the small number of patients with substantial increases in antifungal MICs (Table 6) was not surprising. The highest rise in fluconazole MIC (from 0.5 μg/ml to 32 μg/ml after three courses of fluconazole over a 7-month period) occurred in a middle-aged woman with a history of chronic sinusitis, urinary tract infections, and vaginal yeast infections who was referred to an immunologist for further evaluation. She had low-titer antibody responses to pneumococcal and tetanus vaccines, but normal immunoglobulin G levels. Every vaginal culture collected from this patient during the study period yielded C. parapsilosis. In addition to fluconazole, therapy included boric acid, nystatin, econazole, itraconazole, gentian violet, topical amphotericin B, and topical flucytosine. This patient was still symptomatic with yeast seen on wet mount 3 years after her first vulvovaginitis clinic visit and is an unfortunate example of the difficult challenge treatment of these patients may present.
The conclusions that can be drawn from the epidemiologic data from the current study are limited because of the retrospective collection of information and the lack of a control group. Fidel and Sobel presented a complex model for the immunopathogenesis of recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis and concluded recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis is not caused by impaired systemic cell-mediated immunity, but they postulated a host defect in local vaginal mucosa immunity (8). Factors known to impact the vaginal environment and contribute to vulvovaginal candidiasis (antibiotic therapy, diabetes, and hormone therapy) were present in a minority of the patients with multiple positive cultures in the current study, and only two patients had an immunodeficiency diagnosis. A notable portion of patients in the current study had multiple yeast species isolated from a single culture and changes in species isolated over time. The paucity of predisposing conditions, the diversity among infecting yeast, and the predominance of antifungal-susceptible C. albicans isolates support a host defect in vaginal mucosal immunity as a key factor in the pathogenesis of recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis. However, the increased prevalence of non-albicans species (42%) with higher azole MICs among patients with multiple positive cultures in the current study suggests antifungal resistance may also be an important factor for some patients.
The high frequency with which C. albicans was recovered in this study and its azole susceptibility support the continued use of azole agents for empirical therapy of uncomplicated candidal vulvovaginitis. Cultures from patients with recurrent candidal vulvovaginitis should be obtained to detect non-albicans species that are less likely to respond to an azole agent. Prospective studies with control groups are needed to determine the optimal therapy for candidal vulvovaginitis caused by non-albicans species.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank Holly Huynh and Linda Boyken for assistance with susceptibility testing and Lena Jaspering for assistance with medical record acquisition.
Financial support for this study was provided by Pfizer Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
M.A.P. and D.J.D. have received research funding from Pfizer, Schering, Vicuron, and Fujisawa. M.A.P. and D.J.D. are members of the speakers' bureau for Pfizer and Merck. S.S.R. has received research funding from Pfizer. For all other authors, there is no conflict.
REFERENCES
Arzeni, D., M. Del Poeta, O. Simonnetti, A. M. Offidani, L. Lamura, M. Balducci, N. Cester, A. Giacometti, and G. Scalise. 1997. Prevalence and antifungal susceptibility of vaginal yeasts in outpatients attending a gynecological center in Ancona, Italy. Eur. J. Epidemiol. 13:447-450.
Bauters, T. G. M., M. A. Dhont, M. I. Temmerman, and H. J. Nelis. 2002. Prevalence of vulvovaginal candidiasis and susceptibility to fluconazole in women. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 187:569-574.
Berg, A. O., F. E. Heidrich, S. D. Fihn, J. J. Bergman, R. W. Wood, W. E. Stamm, and K. K. Holmes. 1984. Establishing the cause of genitourinary symptoms in women in a family practice: comparison of clinical examination and comprehensive microbiology. JAMA 251:620-625.
Blignaut, E., S. Messer, R. J. Hollis, and M. A. Pfaller. 2002. Antifungal susceptibility of South African oral yeast isolates from HIV/AIDS patients and healthy individuals. Diagn. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 44:169-174.
Carrillo-Munoz, A. J., G. Quindos, C. Tur, M. T. Ruesga, Y. Miranda, O. del Valle, P. A. Cossum, and T. L. Wallace. 1999. In-vitro antifungal activity of liposomal nystatin in comparison with nystatin, amphotericin B cholesteryl sulphate, liposomal amphotericin B, amphotericin B lipid complex, amphotericin B desoxycholate, fluconazole, and itraconazole. J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 44:397-401.
Dorrell, L., and A. Edwards. 2002. Vulvovaginitis due to fluconazole resistant Candida albicans following self treatment with non-prescribed triazoles. Sex. Transm. Infect. 78:308.
El-Din, S. S., M. T. Reynolds, H. R. Ashbee, R. C. Barton, and E. G. V. Evans. 2001. An investigation into the pathogenesis of vulvovaginal candidosis. Sex. Transm. Infect. 77:179-183.
Fidel, P. L., and J. D. Sobel. 1996. Immunopathogenesis of recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis. Clin. Microbiol. Rev. 9:335-348.
Holland, J., M. L. Young, O. Lee, and C.-A. Chen. 2003. Vulvovaginal carriage of yeasts other than Candida albicans. Sex. Transm. Infect. 79:249.
Lynch, M. E., and J. D. Sobel. 1994. Comparative in vitro activity of antimycotic agents against pathogenic vaginal yeast isolates. J. Med. Vet. Mycol. 32:267-274.
Mathema, B., E. Cross, E. Dun, S. Park, J. Bedell, B. Slade, M. Williams, L. Riley, V. Chaturvedi, and D. S. Perlin. 2001. Prevalence of vaginal colonization by drug-resistant Candida species in college-age women with previous exposure to over-the-counter azole antifungals. Clin. Infect. Dis. 33:e23-e27.
McCormack, W. M., Jr., S. H. Zinner, and W. M. McCormack. 1994. The incidence of genitourinary infections in a cohort of healthy women. Sex. Transm. Dis. 21:63-64.
National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards. 2002. Reference method for broth dilution antifungal susceptibility testing for yeasts. Approved standard M27-A2, 2nd ed. National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards, Wayne, Pa.
Nyirjesy, P., M. V. Weitz, M. H. T. Grody, and B. Lorber. 1997. Over-the-counter and alternative medicines in the treatment of chronic vaginal symptoms. Obstet. Gynecol. 90:50-53.
Nyirjesy, P., S. M. Seeney, M. H. T. Grody, C. A. Jordan, and H. R. Buckley. 1995. Chronic fungal vaginitis: the value of cultures. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 173:820-823.
Pfaller, M. A., and D. J. Diekema. 2002. Role of sentinel surveillance of candidemia: trends in species distribution and antifungal susceptibility. J. Clin. Microbiol. 40:3551-3557.
Pfaller, M. A., D. J. Diekema, S. A. Messer, L. Boyken, and R. J. Hollis. 2003. Activities of fluconazole and voriconazole against 1,586 recent clinical isolates of Candida species determined by broth microdilution, disk diffusion, and Etest methods: report from the ARTEMIS global antifungal susceptibility program, 2001. J. Clin. Microbiol. 41:1440-1446.
Pfaller, M. A., S. A. Messer, R. J. Hollis, R. N. Jones, G. V. Doern, M. E. Brandt, and R. A. Hajjeh. 1999. Trends in species distribution and susceptibility to fluconazole among blood stream isolates of Candida species in the United States. Diagn. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 33:217-222.
Rex, J. H., and M. A. Pfaller. 2002. Has antifungal susceptibility testing come of age Clin. Infect. Dis. 35:982-989.
Ribeiro, M. A., R. Dietze, C. R. Paula, D. A. Da Matta, and A. L. Colombo. 2000. Susceptibility profile of vaginal yeast isolates from Brazil. Mycopathologia 151:5-10.
Singh, S., J. D. Sobel, P. Bhargava, D. Boikov, and J. A. Vazquez. 2002. Vaginitis due to Candida krusei: epidemiology, clinical aspects, and therapy. Clin. Infect. Dis. 35:1066-1070.
Sobel, J. D., and W. Chaim. 1997. Treatment of Torulopsis glabrata vaginitis: retrospective review of boric acid therapy. Clin. Infect. Dis. 24:649-652.
Sobel, J. D., W. Chaim, V. Nagappan, and D. Leaman. 2003. Treatment of vaginitis caused by Candida glabrata: use of topical boric acid and flucytosine. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 189:1297-1300.
Sobel, J. D., S. Faro, R. W. Force, B. Foxman, W. J. Ledger, P. R. Nyirjesy, B. D. Reed, and P. R. Summers. 1998. Vulvovaginal candidiasis: epidemiologic, diagnostic, and therapeutic considerations. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 178:203-211.
Sobel, J. D., and J. A. Vazquez. 1996. Symptomatic vulvovaginitis due to fluconazole-resistant Candida albicans in a female who was not infected with human immunodeficiency virus. Clin. Infect. Dis. 22:726-727.
Sobel, J. D., J. Vazquez, M. Lynch, C. Meriwether, and M. J. Zervos. 1993. Vaginitis due to Saccharomyces cerevisiae: epidemiology, clinical aspects, and therapy. Clin. Infect. Dis. 16:93-99.
Sobel, J. D., H. C. Wiesenfeld, M. Martens, P. Danna, T. M. Hooton, A. Rompalo, M. Sperling, C. Livengood III, B. Horowitz, J. V. Thron, L. Edwards, H. Panzer, and T.-C. Chu. 2004. Maintenance fluconazole therapy for recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis. N. Engl. J. Med. 351:876-883.
Sobel, J. D., M. Zervos, B. D. Reed, T. Hooton, D. Soper, P. Nyirjesy, M. W. Heine, J. Willems, and H. Panzer. 2003. Fluconazole susceptibility of vaginal isolates obtained from women with complicated Candida vaginitis: clinical implications. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 47:34-38.
Spinillo, A., E. Capuzzo, R. Gulminetti, P. Marone, L. Colonna, and G. Piazzi. 1997. Prevalence of and risk factors for fungal vaginitis caused by non-albicans species. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 176:138-141.
Swate, T. E., and J. C. Weed. 1974. Boric acid treatment of vulvovaginal candidiasis. Obstet. Gynecol. 43:893-895.(Sandra S. Richter, Rudolp)