The many faces of sex work
http://www.100md.com
《性传输感染》
1 Sydney Sexual Health Centre, Sydney Hospital, Sydney, Australia
2 School of Public Health, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia
ABSTRACT
Objective: To compile a global typography of commercial sex work.
Methods: A Medline search and review of 681 "prostitution" articles was conducted. In addition, the investigators pooled their 20 years of collected papers and monographs, and their observations in more than 15 countries. Arbitrary categories were developed to compile a workable typology of sex work.
Results: At least 25 types of sex work were identified according to worksite, principal mode of soliciting clients, or sexual practices. These types of work are often grouped under the headings of "direct" and "indirect" prostitution, with the latter group less likely to be perceived or to perceive themselves as sex workers. In general, policing sex work can change its typology and location but its prevalence is rarely affected. The public health implications of sex work vary widely.
Conclusion: Developing comprehensive sexual health promotion programmes requires a complete understanding of the types of sex work in a particular area. This study provides a checklist for developing appropriate and targeted programmes.
Keywords: sex work
Sex work, or prostitution, is the provision of sexual services for money or its equivalent. Sex workers may be male, female, or transgendered, and the boundaries of sex work are vague, ranging from erotic displays without physical contact with the client, through to high risk unprotected sexual intercourse with numerous clients. Individuals may occasionally and opportunistically exact a fee or gift for a sexual favour without perceiving themselves to be sex workers, or they may engage more or less full time in the explicitly commercial provision of sex services. This variability results in a spectrum of implications for public health and health service provision; yet sex work is typically stigmatised and often criminalised.
Particularly in developing countries, interventions with sex workers—health education, screening, and treatment for sexually transmitted infections, and condom supply—are the most cost effective HIV control strategy.1 Developing appropriate interventions requires a comprehensive picture of the shape and location of local sex industries.2 To aid programme managers in this task, we sought to develop a typology of sex work that can be used as a checklist for situation assessments.
METHODS
A Medline search and review of 681 "prostitution" articles published in English from 1996–2004 was conducted. In addition, the investigators pooled their 20 years of collected papers and monographs on sex work, as well as observations in more than 15 countries, particularly in the Asia-Pacific region and Latin America. These included direct field notes, conference presentations, government and non-government inquiries, national HIV programme assessments, and advice from key local informants.
The broad grouping of "direct" and "indirect" sex workers was used because it is already in general usage, particularly in Asia. The narrower categories were arbitrarily based on worksite, mode of soliciting clients, or type of sexual services provided. The broad categories of "high class" and "low class," reflecting the sex worker’s income, was considered but not used in the main typology because income is a continuum and different "classes" of sex worker can be found in any one type of sex work. Our initial aim was to illustrate the variety of social contexts in which prostitution occurs.
RESULTS
Types and social contexts of sex work
Only in the most extreme social situations, such as the Cultural Revolution in 1960s China3 and the Taliban regime in Afghanistan, has commercial sex probably been quantitatively suppressed. Typically social and legal sanctions against sex workers merely succeed in displacing the activity into other localities4,5 or into a different kind of working arrangement.6,7 Every country, and every region within those countries, has a different composition to its sex industry—shaped by history, social and economic factors, legal framework, and policing practices.
The reasons why people take money or gifts for sex are very varied. In some ancient traditions prostitution was recognised as the hereditary calling of particular subgroups or castes. In these cases women were "born into prostitution." There are echoes of this practice in India and Nepal where descendents of temple dancers (Devadasis) and female court musicians (Nautch girls) still follow their "hereditary" calling, although their ritual significance is greatly diminished.8,9
Currently most sex work has a strong economic basis, primarily as a source of income for sex workers, but also for dependent kin and associates including pimps, managers, and ancillary workers.10 Individual sex workers have very different levels of need ranging from survival,11 debt,12 drug dependency,13 coercion,14 and social connection,15 to desire for wealth and social mobility.15,16 These underlying motives affect the sex worker’s autonomy and ability to respond to health promotion messages.17 For example, a refugee with dependent children in a war zone is less empowered to insist that a passing soldier uses a condom than an escort in a wealthy country, who may be supplementing her income to buy a better car.
Direct prostitution
Table 1 lists a variety of sexual services widely recognised as "prostitution" because it is clear that the primary purpose of the interaction is to exchange sex for a fee. These services are referred to as "direct" prostitution, though there is great variety in the social context and possible harms associated with these transactions.
Street or other public place sex work is probably the most widespread type of prostitution globally. Large numbers of street based sex workers can be an indicator of socioeconomic breakdown10 in developing and war torn countries.11 In wealthy countries sex workers are more likely to solicit publicly if legislation denies them access to indoor venues, they are drug dependent, or there is an employment crisis.29
Many sex workers regard street work as undesirable because of the danger of violence and other forms of social hostility.18 Nevertheless some prefer the relative autonomy and unregulated conditions of outdoor work.18 In a minority of settings street work is more lucrative and therefore more prized by sex workers.16,30 Sometimes the lack of privacy limits services to providing oral sex or "hand relief," thus reducing associated health risks.31
Instead of waiting for passing trade, some sex workers actively seek their clients in male dominated venues such as pubs, clubs, hostels or hotels.25 Others frequent transport hubs, servicing travellers and crew for cash or intercity travel.10,26 In an extension of street work, some sex workers in the United States drive their own cars on interstate highways soliciting truck drivers via CB radio.27
Between soliciting in public and indoor sex work are doorway and window prostitution. The red light areas of Hamburg and Amsterdam are well known for their "shop" window sex workers.23 More commonly sex workers in poorer European suburbs, and many parts of the developing world, solicit passing trade from the doorways of small brothels or their own homes.24
Indoor sex work is typified by brothel prostitution. Brothels vary enormously in their size and décor from mere hovels through tenement bedrooms to elaborate "pleasure palaces" with lavish fantasy themes. Brothels also vary in their administration from individual "houses" to fully staffed business enterprises. The human rights and working conditions of brothel prostitutes are similarly varied, but brothels generally offer greater security than the street in terms of personal safety and the ability to provide some health care and education. Brothel prostitution is found in most places where there is a significant sex industry and it is the form most likely to be the subject of state regulation.
Another widespread form of indoor prostitution is escort prostitution where sex workers are contacted by phone and travel to the clients’ premises. Escort agencies may operate internationally.7 Escort services have the advantage of being covert and are therefore better tolerated by law enforcers and the community at large. However, escort sex workers are potentially exposed to violence from clients and may have less access to health care than brothel workers.
Private sex workers working alone or in small groups from "residential" premises are a significant sector of the industry in Australia, the United Kingdom, and many other parts of the world.19,21,22 Private sex workers in developed countries, unlike doorway prostitutes, do not rely on passing trade but require their clients to make appointments by phone. Thus, although they often work alone they are able to control their work environment and preselect their clients to a considerable degree. It is difficult to measure the sexual health and welfare parameters of private workers because, like escorts, they work covertly.
Indirect prostitution
Prostitution is not always the sole or primary source of income for individuals, even in relatively impoverished settings. It can provide additional income for lowly or irregularly paid workers in other industries.10 In these cases the transaction may not be recognised as prostitution. Consequently the personal and public health risks may be greater than in the "direct" sex industry.31 During the Great Depression in Australia "amateur prostitutes" (sometimes part-time prostitutes, often any women engaging in casual sex) were blamed for a significant proportion of venereal disease in the community.32,33 Similar blame was levelled at "good time girls" who accompanied foreign servicemen on wartime leave in Sydney.34 Where a prostitution licensing regime exists "clandestinas" (unregistered sex workers) are more at risk than full time, registered sex workers.35
There are some indirect sexual services (bondage and discipline, lap dancing, massage (table 2)) that involve little or no genital contact and therefore have little sexual health risk.36 Even less risky are services such as telephone sex and the various forms of internet (virtual) sex which only become a public health concern if they precede an actual sexual relationship. These services are mostly confined to wealthier countries.
Other forms of indirect prostitution involve genital intercourse, but only after a previous transaction, such as the purchase of beer, or a massage, or some form of entertainment, has occurred.37–39 These and other forms of opportunistic sex, including sex for drugs exchanges, can have major public health implications.13 Frequently, both the sex worker and the client view these transactions as unplanned, spur of the moment decisions. Therefore, sexual health precautions are unlikely to be observed and the participants may not recollect the acts as potentially hazardous "prostitution." Often they will have consumed quantities of drugs or alcohol before having sex. Clandestine sex, whether commercial or not, often happens outdoors or in places without hygiene facilities and where haste overrides other precautions.
In "individual arrangements," including "femmes libres"41 and sex workers with regular clients, the service providers may have a false sense of security based on a perception of freedom of choice.43 However, their clients are frequently even less constrained. Sometimes, where customary relationships differ widely between neighbouring communities, one sexual partner may interpret a transaction as prostitution, while the other understands it as casual sex or short term companionate love.44 Even more, in the case of survival or necessity driven transactions, the relative desperation and poverty of the sex worker can undermine basic health and safety considerations.11
"Long time" arrangements, where a sex worker is engaged as a live-in companion (Bali), "minor wife" (Thailand), or "outside wife" (sub-Saharan Africa)22,44,45 have pitfalls for both the client, who may believe he has avoided the risks of "commercial" sex by the arrangement, and the sex worker whose status at best is one of temporary concubinage and at worst is sex slavery. These arrangements infer large economic and power disparities between the sex worker and the client.
Other factors affecting the health and welfare of sex workers
The locational and circumstantial contexts of sex work are important in estimating the potential health hazards of prostitution, but there are other critical cross cutting factors. An important variable is the number of clients a sex worker sees during a typical working shift. High volumes of clients over relatively short periods are linked to high levels of STI and other poor health outcomes.1,46 However, this is dramatically modified by the consistent use of condoms and the relative prosperity of sex workers and their community.21,47,48 High numbers of clients associated with low income prostitution produces much worse outcomes.30,49,50
Low income, in turn, is related to a number of factors. Sex workers in impoverished communities in developing countries earn little, and have very limited, if any, access to condoms and health services. Coerced sex workers are often forced to service large numbers of clients to maximise the profits of pimps and traffickers. Even without overt coercion, expenses imposed on sex workers (by minders, managers, corrupt officials, and court fines) may force them to work more intensely and for longer shifts than in more tolerant environments. Many sex workers have to see more clients because they are unable to charge an appropriate fee for services. Often very young and older sex workers are exploited in this way. Similarly, illegal, immigrant, homeless, mobile, and/or physically and socially isolated sex workers are less able to negotiate adequate prices for their services, particularly when many of their clients are similarly disadvantaged.28,51,52
Compulsive and addictive behaviour involving drugs, alcohol, or gambling can motivate prostitution and increase the number of clients. As noted above the presence of these factors reduces the judgment and discretion of sex workers in health matters. They may equally be a reason for avoiding legal, health, and welfare services.
Trafficking and sex slavery
For centuries people have crossed borders to provide cheap labour including sex work.53 Currently, these issues are matters of debate because of the global spread of HIV and the major labour migrations from eastern Europe, South America, and parts of Africa and Asia. Though travel and migration for the purposes of sex work are usually voluntary, sometimes they are not—giving rise to emotional language such as "trafficking" and "sex slavery." Coerced prostitution is morally repugnant, but the current debate has failed to clarify the real issues relating to individual agency (choice) and the protection of human rights (including sex worker rights), in the context of trade globalisation and labour restriction.53
Male and transgender sex work
Male and transgender sex work can assume any of the forms associated with female sex work. The client base is almost always male.20,42 In spite of this many young and/or drug dependent male sex workers in wealthier countries self identify as heterosexual. Their clients, similarly, may be "gay," "bisexual," or "straight."54 Equally, many female sex workers self identify as lesbian. When male sex workers self identify as homosexual the distinction between work and play is sometimes blurred.20,55 Typically located near resorts in poorer countries, young men—"bumsters" or "beachboys"—hire themselves to wealthy western women for social and sexual purposes. "Gigolos" are a half mythical upmarket form of bumster.42
Key messages
Sex work is ubiquitous and takes many forms
The public health implications of sex work vary greatly
Much sex work is conducted under the guise of other activities
Indirect and covert sex workers are less likely to benefit from health promotion programmes
Child prostitution
Child prostitution is reviled everywhere though serious moves to reduce its prevalence through the active international pursuit of its clients and organisers, are relatively recent. Child prostitution is ubiquitous and can take any of the above forms.
CONCLUSIONS
In summary, prostitution varies enormously in its forms and social contexts. The health and personal safety of sex workers depends to a considerable degree on the context and location of their transactions and the intensity of their working life (table 3).
Almost everywhere there are laws designed to limit and control prostitution but they rarely achieve their desired effect. Laws against prostitution organisers may temporarily reduce the activity but also drive it into more covert forms.5–7 Laws punishing prostitutes further reduce their power to protect themselves and leave them vulnerable to arbitrary and corrupt behaviour by officials.29 Where prostitution is regulated by licensing, sex workers outside the system are doubly compromised as far as their health and safety is concerned, with potentially far reaching public health effects.35,56
Commensurate with the economic basis of prostitution, health outcomes are generally better where sex workers have a higher status measured by their ability to earn a good income, be selective about their clients and their services, and be supported by adequately resourced health services and community based organisations.
CONTRIBUTORS
BD sketched out the original idea. Both authors pooled their research material; CH wrote the first draft which was then amended and modified by BD; CH was responsible for the paper’s final draft and submission
FOOTNOTES
Conflict of interest: none.
REFERENCES
Jha P, Nagelkereke NJD, Ngugi EN, et al. Reducing HIV transmission in developing countries. Science 2001;292:224–5.
Day S, Ward H. Sex workers and the control of sexually transmitted disease. Genitourin Med 1997;73:161–8.
Cohen MS, Henderson GE, Aiello P. et al Successful eradication of sexually transmitted diseases in the People’s Republic of China: implications for the 21st century. J Infect Dis 1996;174 (Suppl 2) :S223–9.
Larsen EN. The effect of different police enforcement policies on the control of prostitution. Canadian Public Policy 1996;XXII:40–55.
Neave M . The failure of prostitution law reform. A NZ J Criminol 1988;21:202–13.
Allen J . The making of a prostitute proletariat in early twentieth century New South Wales. In: Daniels K, ed. So much hard work. Women and prostitution in Australian history. Sydney: Fontana/Collins, 1984:192–232.
Ward H, Day S, Green A, et al. Declining prevalence of STI in the London sex industry 1985–2002. Sex Transm Infect 2004;80:374–8.
Bhatt P, Gurubacharya VL, Vadies G. A unique community of family-oriented prostitutes in Nepal uninfected by HIV-1. Int J STD AIDS 1993;4:280–3.
Khanna N, Nadkarni V, Bhutani LK. India. In: Brown T, Chan R, Mugrditchian D, et al, eds. Sexually transmitted diseases in Asia and the Pacific. Armidale, NSW, Venereology Publishing: East-West Center, Thai Red Cross, 1998:114–37.
Aral SO, St. Lawrence JS, Tikhonova L, et al. The social organization of commercial sex work in Moscow, Russia. Sex Transm Dis 2003;30:39–45.
Hankins CA, Friedman SR, Zafar T, et al. Transmission and prevention of HIV and sexually transmitted infections in war settings: implications for current and future armed conflicts. (Editorial review) AIDS 2002;16:2245–52.
Evans C, Lambert H. Health-seeking strategies and sexual health among female sex workers in urban India: implications for research and service provision. Soc Sci Med 1997;44:1791–803.
Inciardi JA. Crack, crack house sex, and HIV risk. Arch Sex Behav 1995;24:249–69.
Cwikel J, Ilan K, Chudakov B. Women brothel workers and occupational health risks. J Epidemiol Commun Health 2003;57:809–15.
Campbell C . Selling sex in the time of AIDS: the psycho-social context of condom use by sex workers on a southern African mine. Soc Sci Med 2000;50:479–94.
Agha S, Nchima NC. Life circumstances, working conditions and HIV risk among street and nightclub-based sex workers in Lusaka, Zambia. Culture, Health and Sexuality 2004;6:283–99.
Harcourt C, Donovan B. Sex workers. In: Fairley CK, Russell D, Bradford DL, eds. Sexual health medicine: a clinical perspective. Melbourne: IP Communications, 2005:424–9.
Harcourt C, van Beek I, Heslop J, et al. The health and welfare of female and transgender sex workers in New South Wales. A NZ J Public Health 2001;25:84–9.
Wade A, Mateljan G. Research fieldwork among sex workers. In: Perkins R, Prestage G, Sharp R, et al, eds. Sex work and sex workers in Australia. Sydney: UNSW Press, 1994:292–300.
Waldorf D, Murphy S. Intravenous drug use and syringe-sharing practices of call men and hustlers. In: Plant MA, ed. AIDS drugs and prostitution. London: Routledge, 1990:109–31.
Ward H, Day S, Weber J. Risky business: health and safety in the sex industry over a 9 year period. Sex Transm Infect 1999;75:340–3.
Ford K, Wirawan DN, Fajans P. AIDS knowledge, risk behaviours, and condom use among four groups of female sex workers in Bali, Indonesia. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Human Retrovirol 1995;10:569–76.
Venema PU, Visser J. Safer prostitution: a new approach in Holland. In: Plant MA, ed. AIDS, drugs, and prostitution. London: Routledge, 1990:41–60.
Asamoah-Adu C, Khonde N, Avorkliah M, et al. HIV infection among sex workers in Accra: need to target new recruits entering the trade. J AIDS 2001;28:358–66.
Blackmore CA, Limpakarnjanarat K, Rigau-Pérez JG, et al. An outbreak of chancroid in Orange County, California: descriptive epidemiology and disease-control measures. J Infect Dis 1985;151:840–4.
Singh YN, Malaviya AN. Long distance truck drivers in India: HIV infection and their possible role in disseminating HIV into rural areas. Int J STD AIDS 1994;5:137–8.
Luxenburg J, Klein L. CB radio prostitution: technology and the displacement of deviance. In: Chaneles S, ed. Gender issues, sex offences, and criminal justice: current trends. New York: The Haworth Press, 1984:71–87.
Kulick D . Sex in the new Europe: the criminalization of clients and Swedish fear of penetration. Anthropological Theory 2003;3:199–218.
Allen J . Sex and secrets. Crimes involving Australian women since 1880. Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1990:189–94.
Dada AJ, Oyewole F, Onofowokan R, et al. Demographic characteristics of retroviral infections (HIV-1, HIV-2, and HTLV-1) among female professional sex workers in Lagos, Nigeria. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 1993;6:1358–63.
Jackson L, Highcrest A, Coates RA. Varied potential risks of HIV infection among prostitutes. Soc Sci Med 1992;35:281–6.
Sponberg M . Feminizing venereal disease. The body of the prostitute in nineteenth century medical discourse. London: Macmillan Press, 1997:176–82.
Cumpston JHL. Health and disease in Australia. A history. (Introduced and edited by MJ Lewis). Canberra: AGPS, 1989:268–9.
Frances R . The history of female prostitution in Australia. In: Perkins R, Prestage G, Sharp R, Lovejoy F, eds. Sex work and sex workers in Australia. Sydney: UNSW Press, 1994:27–52.
Stary A, Kopp W, S?ltz-Sz?ts J. Medical health care for Viennese prostitutes. Sex Transm Dis 1991;18:159–65.
Blain R . A female sex worker’s view. In: Perkins R, Prestage G, Sharp R, et al, eds. Sex work and sex workers in Australia. Sydney: UNSW Press, 1994:113–25.
Josoef MR, Linnan M, Barakbah Y, et al. Patterns of sexually transmitted diseases in female sex workers in Surabaya, Indonesia. Int J STD AIDS 1997;8:576–80.
Thuy NTT, Nhung VT, Thuc NV, et al. HIV infection and risk factors among female sex workers in southern Vietnam. AIDS 1998;12:425–32.
Leng HB. Cambodia. In: Brown T, Chan R, Mugrditchian D, et al, eds. Sexually transmitted diseases in Asia and the Pacific. Armidale, NSW, Venereology Publishing: East-West Center, Thai Red Cross, 1998:62–71.
Gysels M, Pool R, Nnalisuba B. Women who sell sex in a Ugandan trading town: life histories, survival strategies and risk. Soc Sci Med 2002;54:179–92.
La Fontaine JS. The free women of Kinshasa: prostitution in a city in Za?re. In: Davis J, ed. Choice and change. Essays in honour of Lucy Mair. London: The Athlone Press, 1974:89–113.
Ford K, Wirawan DN, Fajans P, et al. AIDS knowledge, risk behaviours, and factors related to condom use among male commercial sex workers and male tourist clients in Bali, Indonesia. AIDS 1995;9:751–9.
Sedyaningsih-Mamahit ER. Determinants of safer-sex behaviours of brothel female commercial sex workers in Jakarta, Indonesia. J Sex Res 1999;36:190–7.
Larson A . Social context of human immunodeficiency virus transmission in Africa: historical and cultural bases of east and central African sexual relations. Reviews of Infectious Diseases 1989;11:716–31.
Peracca S, Knodel J, Saengtienchai C. Can prostitutes marry? Thai attitudes toward female sex workers. Soc Sci Med 1998;47:255–67.
Donovan B . Medico-social aspects of a house of prostitution. Med J Aust 1984;140:272–5.
Vioque J, Hernández-Aguado I, Garcia EF, et al. Prospective cohort study of female sex workers and the risk of HIV infection in Alicante, Spain (1986–96). Sex Transm Inf 1998;74:284–8.
Donovan B, Harcourt C. The female sex industry in Australia: a health promotion model. Venereology 1996;9:63–7.
McKeganey NP. Prostitution and HIV: what do we know and where might research be targeted in the future? (Editorial review) AIDS 1994;8:1215–26.
Kreiss JK, Koech D, Plummer FA, et al. AIDS virus infection in Nairobi prostitutes—spread of the epidemic to East Africa. N Engl J Med 1986;314:414–18.
Van Haastrecht HJA, Fennema JSA, Coutinho RA, et al. HIV prevalence and risk behaviour among prostitutes and clients in Amsterdam: migrants at increased risk for HIV infection. Genitourin Med 1993;69:251–6.
O’Connor CC, Berry G, Rohrsheim R, et al. Sexual health and use of condoms among local and international sex workers in Sydney. Genitourin Med 1996;72:47–51.
Butcher K . Confusion between prostitution and sex trafficking. Lancet 2003;361:1983.
Minichiello V, Marino R, Browne J, et al. A profile of the clients of male sex workers in three Australian cities. A NZ J Pub Health 1999;23:511–18.
Plummer D, Brown T, Mulhall B, et al. Cultures, sexualities, and health in Asia and the Pacific. In: Brown T, Chan R, Mugrditchian D, et al, eds. Sexually transmitted diseases in Asia and the Pacific. Armidale NSW, Venereology Publishing: East-West Center, Thai Red Cross, 1998:1–25.
Moreton A, Wakefield T, Tabrizi SN, et al. An outreach programme for sexually transmitted infection screening in street sex workers using self-administered samples Int J STD AIDS 1999;24:503–15.(C Harcourt and B Donovan)
2 School of Public Health, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia
ABSTRACT
Objective: To compile a global typography of commercial sex work.
Methods: A Medline search and review of 681 "prostitution" articles was conducted. In addition, the investigators pooled their 20 years of collected papers and monographs, and their observations in more than 15 countries. Arbitrary categories were developed to compile a workable typology of sex work.
Results: At least 25 types of sex work were identified according to worksite, principal mode of soliciting clients, or sexual practices. These types of work are often grouped under the headings of "direct" and "indirect" prostitution, with the latter group less likely to be perceived or to perceive themselves as sex workers. In general, policing sex work can change its typology and location but its prevalence is rarely affected. The public health implications of sex work vary widely.
Conclusion: Developing comprehensive sexual health promotion programmes requires a complete understanding of the types of sex work in a particular area. This study provides a checklist for developing appropriate and targeted programmes.
Keywords: sex work
Sex work, or prostitution, is the provision of sexual services for money or its equivalent. Sex workers may be male, female, or transgendered, and the boundaries of sex work are vague, ranging from erotic displays without physical contact with the client, through to high risk unprotected sexual intercourse with numerous clients. Individuals may occasionally and opportunistically exact a fee or gift for a sexual favour without perceiving themselves to be sex workers, or they may engage more or less full time in the explicitly commercial provision of sex services. This variability results in a spectrum of implications for public health and health service provision; yet sex work is typically stigmatised and often criminalised.
Particularly in developing countries, interventions with sex workers—health education, screening, and treatment for sexually transmitted infections, and condom supply—are the most cost effective HIV control strategy.1 Developing appropriate interventions requires a comprehensive picture of the shape and location of local sex industries.2 To aid programme managers in this task, we sought to develop a typology of sex work that can be used as a checklist for situation assessments.
METHODS
A Medline search and review of 681 "prostitution" articles published in English from 1996–2004 was conducted. In addition, the investigators pooled their 20 years of collected papers and monographs on sex work, as well as observations in more than 15 countries, particularly in the Asia-Pacific region and Latin America. These included direct field notes, conference presentations, government and non-government inquiries, national HIV programme assessments, and advice from key local informants.
The broad grouping of "direct" and "indirect" sex workers was used because it is already in general usage, particularly in Asia. The narrower categories were arbitrarily based on worksite, mode of soliciting clients, or type of sexual services provided. The broad categories of "high class" and "low class," reflecting the sex worker’s income, was considered but not used in the main typology because income is a continuum and different "classes" of sex worker can be found in any one type of sex work. Our initial aim was to illustrate the variety of social contexts in which prostitution occurs.
RESULTS
Types and social contexts of sex work
Only in the most extreme social situations, such as the Cultural Revolution in 1960s China3 and the Taliban regime in Afghanistan, has commercial sex probably been quantitatively suppressed. Typically social and legal sanctions against sex workers merely succeed in displacing the activity into other localities4,5 or into a different kind of working arrangement.6,7 Every country, and every region within those countries, has a different composition to its sex industry—shaped by history, social and economic factors, legal framework, and policing practices.
The reasons why people take money or gifts for sex are very varied. In some ancient traditions prostitution was recognised as the hereditary calling of particular subgroups or castes. In these cases women were "born into prostitution." There are echoes of this practice in India and Nepal where descendents of temple dancers (Devadasis) and female court musicians (Nautch girls) still follow their "hereditary" calling, although their ritual significance is greatly diminished.8,9
Currently most sex work has a strong economic basis, primarily as a source of income for sex workers, but also for dependent kin and associates including pimps, managers, and ancillary workers.10 Individual sex workers have very different levels of need ranging from survival,11 debt,12 drug dependency,13 coercion,14 and social connection,15 to desire for wealth and social mobility.15,16 These underlying motives affect the sex worker’s autonomy and ability to respond to health promotion messages.17 For example, a refugee with dependent children in a war zone is less empowered to insist that a passing soldier uses a condom than an escort in a wealthy country, who may be supplementing her income to buy a better car.
Direct prostitution
Table 1 lists a variety of sexual services widely recognised as "prostitution" because it is clear that the primary purpose of the interaction is to exchange sex for a fee. These services are referred to as "direct" prostitution, though there is great variety in the social context and possible harms associated with these transactions.
Street or other public place sex work is probably the most widespread type of prostitution globally. Large numbers of street based sex workers can be an indicator of socioeconomic breakdown10 in developing and war torn countries.11 In wealthy countries sex workers are more likely to solicit publicly if legislation denies them access to indoor venues, they are drug dependent, or there is an employment crisis.29
Many sex workers regard street work as undesirable because of the danger of violence and other forms of social hostility.18 Nevertheless some prefer the relative autonomy and unregulated conditions of outdoor work.18 In a minority of settings street work is more lucrative and therefore more prized by sex workers.16,30 Sometimes the lack of privacy limits services to providing oral sex or "hand relief," thus reducing associated health risks.31
Instead of waiting for passing trade, some sex workers actively seek their clients in male dominated venues such as pubs, clubs, hostels or hotels.25 Others frequent transport hubs, servicing travellers and crew for cash or intercity travel.10,26 In an extension of street work, some sex workers in the United States drive their own cars on interstate highways soliciting truck drivers via CB radio.27
Between soliciting in public and indoor sex work are doorway and window prostitution. The red light areas of Hamburg and Amsterdam are well known for their "shop" window sex workers.23 More commonly sex workers in poorer European suburbs, and many parts of the developing world, solicit passing trade from the doorways of small brothels or their own homes.24
Indoor sex work is typified by brothel prostitution. Brothels vary enormously in their size and décor from mere hovels through tenement bedrooms to elaborate "pleasure palaces" with lavish fantasy themes. Brothels also vary in their administration from individual "houses" to fully staffed business enterprises. The human rights and working conditions of brothel prostitutes are similarly varied, but brothels generally offer greater security than the street in terms of personal safety and the ability to provide some health care and education. Brothel prostitution is found in most places where there is a significant sex industry and it is the form most likely to be the subject of state regulation.
Another widespread form of indoor prostitution is escort prostitution where sex workers are contacted by phone and travel to the clients’ premises. Escort agencies may operate internationally.7 Escort services have the advantage of being covert and are therefore better tolerated by law enforcers and the community at large. However, escort sex workers are potentially exposed to violence from clients and may have less access to health care than brothel workers.
Private sex workers working alone or in small groups from "residential" premises are a significant sector of the industry in Australia, the United Kingdom, and many other parts of the world.19,21,22 Private sex workers in developed countries, unlike doorway prostitutes, do not rely on passing trade but require their clients to make appointments by phone. Thus, although they often work alone they are able to control their work environment and preselect their clients to a considerable degree. It is difficult to measure the sexual health and welfare parameters of private workers because, like escorts, they work covertly.
Indirect prostitution
Prostitution is not always the sole or primary source of income for individuals, even in relatively impoverished settings. It can provide additional income for lowly or irregularly paid workers in other industries.10 In these cases the transaction may not be recognised as prostitution. Consequently the personal and public health risks may be greater than in the "direct" sex industry.31 During the Great Depression in Australia "amateur prostitutes" (sometimes part-time prostitutes, often any women engaging in casual sex) were blamed for a significant proportion of venereal disease in the community.32,33 Similar blame was levelled at "good time girls" who accompanied foreign servicemen on wartime leave in Sydney.34 Where a prostitution licensing regime exists "clandestinas" (unregistered sex workers) are more at risk than full time, registered sex workers.35
There are some indirect sexual services (bondage and discipline, lap dancing, massage (table 2)) that involve little or no genital contact and therefore have little sexual health risk.36 Even less risky are services such as telephone sex and the various forms of internet (virtual) sex which only become a public health concern if they precede an actual sexual relationship. These services are mostly confined to wealthier countries.
Other forms of indirect prostitution involve genital intercourse, but only after a previous transaction, such as the purchase of beer, or a massage, or some form of entertainment, has occurred.37–39 These and other forms of opportunistic sex, including sex for drugs exchanges, can have major public health implications.13 Frequently, both the sex worker and the client view these transactions as unplanned, spur of the moment decisions. Therefore, sexual health precautions are unlikely to be observed and the participants may not recollect the acts as potentially hazardous "prostitution." Often they will have consumed quantities of drugs or alcohol before having sex. Clandestine sex, whether commercial or not, often happens outdoors or in places without hygiene facilities and where haste overrides other precautions.
In "individual arrangements," including "femmes libres"41 and sex workers with regular clients, the service providers may have a false sense of security based on a perception of freedom of choice.43 However, their clients are frequently even less constrained. Sometimes, where customary relationships differ widely between neighbouring communities, one sexual partner may interpret a transaction as prostitution, while the other understands it as casual sex or short term companionate love.44 Even more, in the case of survival or necessity driven transactions, the relative desperation and poverty of the sex worker can undermine basic health and safety considerations.11
"Long time" arrangements, where a sex worker is engaged as a live-in companion (Bali), "minor wife" (Thailand), or "outside wife" (sub-Saharan Africa)22,44,45 have pitfalls for both the client, who may believe he has avoided the risks of "commercial" sex by the arrangement, and the sex worker whose status at best is one of temporary concubinage and at worst is sex slavery. These arrangements infer large economic and power disparities between the sex worker and the client.
Other factors affecting the health and welfare of sex workers
The locational and circumstantial contexts of sex work are important in estimating the potential health hazards of prostitution, but there are other critical cross cutting factors. An important variable is the number of clients a sex worker sees during a typical working shift. High volumes of clients over relatively short periods are linked to high levels of STI and other poor health outcomes.1,46 However, this is dramatically modified by the consistent use of condoms and the relative prosperity of sex workers and their community.21,47,48 High numbers of clients associated with low income prostitution produces much worse outcomes.30,49,50
Low income, in turn, is related to a number of factors. Sex workers in impoverished communities in developing countries earn little, and have very limited, if any, access to condoms and health services. Coerced sex workers are often forced to service large numbers of clients to maximise the profits of pimps and traffickers. Even without overt coercion, expenses imposed on sex workers (by minders, managers, corrupt officials, and court fines) may force them to work more intensely and for longer shifts than in more tolerant environments. Many sex workers have to see more clients because they are unable to charge an appropriate fee for services. Often very young and older sex workers are exploited in this way. Similarly, illegal, immigrant, homeless, mobile, and/or physically and socially isolated sex workers are less able to negotiate adequate prices for their services, particularly when many of their clients are similarly disadvantaged.28,51,52
Compulsive and addictive behaviour involving drugs, alcohol, or gambling can motivate prostitution and increase the number of clients. As noted above the presence of these factors reduces the judgment and discretion of sex workers in health matters. They may equally be a reason for avoiding legal, health, and welfare services.
Trafficking and sex slavery
For centuries people have crossed borders to provide cheap labour including sex work.53 Currently, these issues are matters of debate because of the global spread of HIV and the major labour migrations from eastern Europe, South America, and parts of Africa and Asia. Though travel and migration for the purposes of sex work are usually voluntary, sometimes they are not—giving rise to emotional language such as "trafficking" and "sex slavery." Coerced prostitution is morally repugnant, but the current debate has failed to clarify the real issues relating to individual agency (choice) and the protection of human rights (including sex worker rights), in the context of trade globalisation and labour restriction.53
Male and transgender sex work
Male and transgender sex work can assume any of the forms associated with female sex work. The client base is almost always male.20,42 In spite of this many young and/or drug dependent male sex workers in wealthier countries self identify as heterosexual. Their clients, similarly, may be "gay," "bisexual," or "straight."54 Equally, many female sex workers self identify as lesbian. When male sex workers self identify as homosexual the distinction between work and play is sometimes blurred.20,55 Typically located near resorts in poorer countries, young men—"bumsters" or "beachboys"—hire themselves to wealthy western women for social and sexual purposes. "Gigolos" are a half mythical upmarket form of bumster.42
Key messages
Sex work is ubiquitous and takes many forms
The public health implications of sex work vary greatly
Much sex work is conducted under the guise of other activities
Indirect and covert sex workers are less likely to benefit from health promotion programmes
Child prostitution
Child prostitution is reviled everywhere though serious moves to reduce its prevalence through the active international pursuit of its clients and organisers, are relatively recent. Child prostitution is ubiquitous and can take any of the above forms.
CONCLUSIONS
In summary, prostitution varies enormously in its forms and social contexts. The health and personal safety of sex workers depends to a considerable degree on the context and location of their transactions and the intensity of their working life (table 3).
Almost everywhere there are laws designed to limit and control prostitution but they rarely achieve their desired effect. Laws against prostitution organisers may temporarily reduce the activity but also drive it into more covert forms.5–7 Laws punishing prostitutes further reduce their power to protect themselves and leave them vulnerable to arbitrary and corrupt behaviour by officials.29 Where prostitution is regulated by licensing, sex workers outside the system are doubly compromised as far as their health and safety is concerned, with potentially far reaching public health effects.35,56
Commensurate with the economic basis of prostitution, health outcomes are generally better where sex workers have a higher status measured by their ability to earn a good income, be selective about their clients and their services, and be supported by adequately resourced health services and community based organisations.
CONTRIBUTORS
BD sketched out the original idea. Both authors pooled their research material; CH wrote the first draft which was then amended and modified by BD; CH was responsible for the paper’s final draft and submission
FOOTNOTES
Conflict of interest: none.
REFERENCES
Jha P, Nagelkereke NJD, Ngugi EN, et al. Reducing HIV transmission in developing countries. Science 2001;292:224–5.
Day S, Ward H. Sex workers and the control of sexually transmitted disease. Genitourin Med 1997;73:161–8.
Cohen MS, Henderson GE, Aiello P. et al Successful eradication of sexually transmitted diseases in the People’s Republic of China: implications for the 21st century. J Infect Dis 1996;174 (Suppl 2) :S223–9.
Larsen EN. The effect of different police enforcement policies on the control of prostitution. Canadian Public Policy 1996;XXII:40–55.
Neave M . The failure of prostitution law reform. A NZ J Criminol 1988;21:202–13.
Allen J . The making of a prostitute proletariat in early twentieth century New South Wales. In: Daniels K, ed. So much hard work. Women and prostitution in Australian history. Sydney: Fontana/Collins, 1984:192–232.
Ward H, Day S, Green A, et al. Declining prevalence of STI in the London sex industry 1985–2002. Sex Transm Infect 2004;80:374–8.
Bhatt P, Gurubacharya VL, Vadies G. A unique community of family-oriented prostitutes in Nepal uninfected by HIV-1. Int J STD AIDS 1993;4:280–3.
Khanna N, Nadkarni V, Bhutani LK. India. In: Brown T, Chan R, Mugrditchian D, et al, eds. Sexually transmitted diseases in Asia and the Pacific. Armidale, NSW, Venereology Publishing: East-West Center, Thai Red Cross, 1998:114–37.
Aral SO, St. Lawrence JS, Tikhonova L, et al. The social organization of commercial sex work in Moscow, Russia. Sex Transm Dis 2003;30:39–45.
Hankins CA, Friedman SR, Zafar T, et al. Transmission and prevention of HIV and sexually transmitted infections in war settings: implications for current and future armed conflicts. (Editorial review) AIDS 2002;16:2245–52.
Evans C, Lambert H. Health-seeking strategies and sexual health among female sex workers in urban India: implications for research and service provision. Soc Sci Med 1997;44:1791–803.
Inciardi JA. Crack, crack house sex, and HIV risk. Arch Sex Behav 1995;24:249–69.
Cwikel J, Ilan K, Chudakov B. Women brothel workers and occupational health risks. J Epidemiol Commun Health 2003;57:809–15.
Campbell C . Selling sex in the time of AIDS: the psycho-social context of condom use by sex workers on a southern African mine. Soc Sci Med 2000;50:479–94.
Agha S, Nchima NC. Life circumstances, working conditions and HIV risk among street and nightclub-based sex workers in Lusaka, Zambia. Culture, Health and Sexuality 2004;6:283–99.
Harcourt C, Donovan B. Sex workers. In: Fairley CK, Russell D, Bradford DL, eds. Sexual health medicine: a clinical perspective. Melbourne: IP Communications, 2005:424–9.
Harcourt C, van Beek I, Heslop J, et al. The health and welfare of female and transgender sex workers in New South Wales. A NZ J Public Health 2001;25:84–9.
Wade A, Mateljan G. Research fieldwork among sex workers. In: Perkins R, Prestage G, Sharp R, et al, eds. Sex work and sex workers in Australia. Sydney: UNSW Press, 1994:292–300.
Waldorf D, Murphy S. Intravenous drug use and syringe-sharing practices of call men and hustlers. In: Plant MA, ed. AIDS drugs and prostitution. London: Routledge, 1990:109–31.
Ward H, Day S, Weber J. Risky business: health and safety in the sex industry over a 9 year period. Sex Transm Infect 1999;75:340–3.
Ford K, Wirawan DN, Fajans P. AIDS knowledge, risk behaviours, and condom use among four groups of female sex workers in Bali, Indonesia. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Human Retrovirol 1995;10:569–76.
Venema PU, Visser J. Safer prostitution: a new approach in Holland. In: Plant MA, ed. AIDS, drugs, and prostitution. London: Routledge, 1990:41–60.
Asamoah-Adu C, Khonde N, Avorkliah M, et al. HIV infection among sex workers in Accra: need to target new recruits entering the trade. J AIDS 2001;28:358–66.
Blackmore CA, Limpakarnjanarat K, Rigau-Pérez JG, et al. An outbreak of chancroid in Orange County, California: descriptive epidemiology and disease-control measures. J Infect Dis 1985;151:840–4.
Singh YN, Malaviya AN. Long distance truck drivers in India: HIV infection and their possible role in disseminating HIV into rural areas. Int J STD AIDS 1994;5:137–8.
Luxenburg J, Klein L. CB radio prostitution: technology and the displacement of deviance. In: Chaneles S, ed. Gender issues, sex offences, and criminal justice: current trends. New York: The Haworth Press, 1984:71–87.
Kulick D . Sex in the new Europe: the criminalization of clients and Swedish fear of penetration. Anthropological Theory 2003;3:199–218.
Allen J . Sex and secrets. Crimes involving Australian women since 1880. Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1990:189–94.
Dada AJ, Oyewole F, Onofowokan R, et al. Demographic characteristics of retroviral infections (HIV-1, HIV-2, and HTLV-1) among female professional sex workers in Lagos, Nigeria. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 1993;6:1358–63.
Jackson L, Highcrest A, Coates RA. Varied potential risks of HIV infection among prostitutes. Soc Sci Med 1992;35:281–6.
Sponberg M . Feminizing venereal disease. The body of the prostitute in nineteenth century medical discourse. London: Macmillan Press, 1997:176–82.
Cumpston JHL. Health and disease in Australia. A history. (Introduced and edited by MJ Lewis). Canberra: AGPS, 1989:268–9.
Frances R . The history of female prostitution in Australia. In: Perkins R, Prestage G, Sharp R, Lovejoy F, eds. Sex work and sex workers in Australia. Sydney: UNSW Press, 1994:27–52.
Stary A, Kopp W, S?ltz-Sz?ts J. Medical health care for Viennese prostitutes. Sex Transm Dis 1991;18:159–65.
Blain R . A female sex worker’s view. In: Perkins R, Prestage G, Sharp R, et al, eds. Sex work and sex workers in Australia. Sydney: UNSW Press, 1994:113–25.
Josoef MR, Linnan M, Barakbah Y, et al. Patterns of sexually transmitted diseases in female sex workers in Surabaya, Indonesia. Int J STD AIDS 1997;8:576–80.
Thuy NTT, Nhung VT, Thuc NV, et al. HIV infection and risk factors among female sex workers in southern Vietnam. AIDS 1998;12:425–32.
Leng HB. Cambodia. In: Brown T, Chan R, Mugrditchian D, et al, eds. Sexually transmitted diseases in Asia and the Pacific. Armidale, NSW, Venereology Publishing: East-West Center, Thai Red Cross, 1998:62–71.
Gysels M, Pool R, Nnalisuba B. Women who sell sex in a Ugandan trading town: life histories, survival strategies and risk. Soc Sci Med 2002;54:179–92.
La Fontaine JS. The free women of Kinshasa: prostitution in a city in Za?re. In: Davis J, ed. Choice and change. Essays in honour of Lucy Mair. London: The Athlone Press, 1974:89–113.
Ford K, Wirawan DN, Fajans P, et al. AIDS knowledge, risk behaviours, and factors related to condom use among male commercial sex workers and male tourist clients in Bali, Indonesia. AIDS 1995;9:751–9.
Sedyaningsih-Mamahit ER. Determinants of safer-sex behaviours of brothel female commercial sex workers in Jakarta, Indonesia. J Sex Res 1999;36:190–7.
Larson A . Social context of human immunodeficiency virus transmission in Africa: historical and cultural bases of east and central African sexual relations. Reviews of Infectious Diseases 1989;11:716–31.
Peracca S, Knodel J, Saengtienchai C. Can prostitutes marry? Thai attitudes toward female sex workers. Soc Sci Med 1998;47:255–67.
Donovan B . Medico-social aspects of a house of prostitution. Med J Aust 1984;140:272–5.
Vioque J, Hernández-Aguado I, Garcia EF, et al. Prospective cohort study of female sex workers and the risk of HIV infection in Alicante, Spain (1986–96). Sex Transm Inf 1998;74:284–8.
Donovan B, Harcourt C. The female sex industry in Australia: a health promotion model. Venereology 1996;9:63–7.
McKeganey NP. Prostitution and HIV: what do we know and where might research be targeted in the future? (Editorial review) AIDS 1994;8:1215–26.
Kreiss JK, Koech D, Plummer FA, et al. AIDS virus infection in Nairobi prostitutes—spread of the epidemic to East Africa. N Engl J Med 1986;314:414–18.
Van Haastrecht HJA, Fennema JSA, Coutinho RA, et al. HIV prevalence and risk behaviour among prostitutes and clients in Amsterdam: migrants at increased risk for HIV infection. Genitourin Med 1993;69:251–6.
O’Connor CC, Berry G, Rohrsheim R, et al. Sexual health and use of condoms among local and international sex workers in Sydney. Genitourin Med 1996;72:47–51.
Butcher K . Confusion between prostitution and sex trafficking. Lancet 2003;361:1983.
Minichiello V, Marino R, Browne J, et al. A profile of the clients of male sex workers in three Australian cities. A NZ J Pub Health 1999;23:511–18.
Plummer D, Brown T, Mulhall B, et al. Cultures, sexualities, and health in Asia and the Pacific. In: Brown T, Chan R, Mugrditchian D, et al, eds. Sexually transmitted diseases in Asia and the Pacific. Armidale NSW, Venereology Publishing: East-West Center, Thai Red Cross, 1998:1–25.
Moreton A, Wakefield T, Tabrizi SN, et al. An outreach programme for sexually transmitted infection screening in street sex workers using self-administered samples Int J STD AIDS 1999;24:503–15.(C Harcourt and B Donovan)