Cytogenetic study of the genus Cousinia (Asteraceae, section Serratuloideae) in Iran
http://www.100md.com
《遗传学和分子生物学》
IShahid Beheshti University, Biology Department, Tehran, Iran
IITehran University, Biology Department, Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT
Meiotic studies of ploidy level, chromosome paring and chiasma frequency were performed on 11 Cousinia (Asteraceae) species of the section Serratuloideae. The diploid number of the species studied was 2n = 2x = 24 and 26 so these species possess two different basic numbers (x = 12 or 13), a phenomenon common to other sections of the genus. The chromosome numbers of 9 species are reported here for the first time. When the 2n = 24 and 2n = 26 species were subjected to cluster analysis based on relative meiotic characters two different clusters were formed indicating their distinctness. Our data support the results obtained from morphometry, anatomy, pollen morphology and molecular studies of the genus Cousinia.
Key words: Cousinia, chiasma frequency, cluster analysis, meiosis.
Introduction
The genus Cousinia (Asteraceae) is of worldwide distribution and comprises approximately 672 species, of which about 235 occur in central, western, eastern and southeastern Iran. According to Boissier (1875) the Serratuloideae section contains 9 species while Rechinger (1970) in Flora Iranica considers 11 species for this section.
Earlier reports on Iranian Cousinia are have been confined mainly to taxonomic studies (Ghahreman et al., 1999; Attar and Ghahreman, 2000; 2002) and a few chromosome number reports (Ghaffari and Djavadi, 1998; Ghaffari et al., 2000). Our study reported in this paper was the first cytological analysis of 11 Iranian species of the section Serratuloideae. We also discuss the cytological changes which play a role in the species diversification of this section.
Materials and Methods
Cytological studies were performed on 11 Cousinia species (Table 1), vouchers specimens are being deposited in the Herbarium of Tehran University (HTU), Iran.
For cytological studies young flower buds of each species were collected from at least 10 randomly selected plants and fixed in acetic acid: ethanol (1:3 v/v) for 24 h after which they were washed and preserved in ethanol at 4 °C until used (Sheidai et al., 2002). For each species, squash slides were prepared and stained with 2% (w/v) aqueous aceto-orcein and the chromosome numbers and chiasma frequency determined from 50 pollen mother cells at diakinesis-metaphase I (Sheidai et al., 2002). Due to insufficient number of meiotic cells, chiasma frequency and distribution was not analyzed in C. serratuloides.
In order to determine any significant difference in chiasma frequency and distribution among the species with either chromosome number (n) = 13 or n = 12 we performed analysis of variance (ANOVA) by the least significant differences (LSD) method (Sokal and Rolf, 1995; Sheidai et al., 2002).
Grouping the n = 12 and n = 13 species was performed using various cluster analysis methods including single linkage, unweighted paired group with arithmetic mean (UPGMA) and the WARD method as well as ordination based on principal component analysis (PCA) in each group separately (Podani, 2000; Sheidai et al., 2002). For numerical analyses meiotic characteristics such as chiasma frequency and distribution (terminal and intercalary chiasmata) and chromosomes association (ring and rod bivalents) as well as univalents were used.
For grouping both the species having n = 12 and 13, cluster analysis and PCA ordination was performed using relative meiotic characters (i.e. dividing the mean values of chiasma frequency and bivalents by the chromosome number to obtain meiotic values per chromosome) unaffected by the chromosome number (Sheidai et al., 2002). Euclidean distance was used for cluster analysis.
Results and Discussion
Variation in prophase sub-stages of meiosis-I
The meiotic analysis of the Cousinia species studied showed variation in the prophase sub-stages of meiosis-I (Figure 1, A-D). In the first sub-stage instead of the leptotene and zygotene stages a synezetic knot occurred consisting of thin chromatin strands surrounding the nucleolus and eventually totally covering it (Figure 1, A). Later, paired chromosomes unraveled from the knot and appeared as thick strands, ushering in the pachytene stage (Figure 1, B) of which end-to-end attachment of chromosomes is a feature reported in taxa showing a synezetic knot stage (John et al., 1989; Sheidai and Inamdar, 1991).
After pachytene, decompaction of the chromosomes occurs, commencing with the diffuse stage (Figure 1, C-D), which has been reported in several plant species (Sybenga, 1992), which may be complete with whole chromosomes undergoing decompaction or partial in which only part of the genome becomes decompacted. Our study showed an almost complete diffuse stage in the Cousinia species examined. Various reasons have been suggested for the occurrence of the diffuse stage, including high synthetic activity (i.e. the lampbrush stage in amphibian oocytes), shedding of the lateral elements of the synaptonemal complex, post pachytene elimination or modification of histone proteins and meiotic arrest to withstand adverse environmental conditions (John et al., 1989; Sheidai et al., 2003). We were not able to determine the exact reason for the occurrence of a diffuse stage in the Cousinia species studied by us but since these species grow in regions of Iran where the environmental conditions are harsh it may be an adaptation to these conditions. Unusual meiosis occurs in Cousinia species with different chromosome numbers, as has been reported in diploid and polyploid species of other plant groups (Sheidai and Inamdar, 1991) and the genomic control of the diffuse stage is not affected by ploidy level.
Chromosome number, chiasma frequency and distribution
Of the Cousinia species studied by us, elbursensis, pinarocephala, pterocaulos and crispa were n = 12 while adenostegia, concolor, hypoleuca irritans, sheidaei, discolor and serratuloides were n = 13 (Table 2, Figure 2). Except for C. crispa and C. hypoleuca this is the first time that chromosome numbers have been published for these species. In general, our study supports the chromosome number reported for C. hypoleuca by Afzal-Rafii (1980), although this author reported 2n = 26 for C. crispa as opposed to the n = 12 (2n = 24) which we recorded for this species. Our data shows that two different basic chromosome numbers (12 or 13) occur in the Serratuloideae section, a similar situation having been reported for other Cousinia sections including Cousinia and Leiocaules (both either n = 12 or 13) and Eriocousinia (n = 11 or 13, Susana et al., 2003). These data suggest aneuploidy, most probably by chromosome reduction during the evolution of the genus Cousinia (Susana et al., 2003).
Data on chiasma frequency and distribution as well as chromosome pairing is presented in Table 2. For the n = 12 species, C. elbursensis had the highest total number of chiasmata (17.00) and terminal chiasmata (16.90), while the highest number of intercalary chiasmata (0.70) occurred in C. pinarocephala and C. crispa. Among the n = 13 species the highest number of total and terminal chiasmata and ring bivalents occurred in C. discolor while the lowest values occurred in C. hypoleuca (Table 2). It is interesting to note that C. adenostegia, C. irritans and C. discolor did not form intercalary chiasmata but showed terminal chiasmata only (Table 2). Variation in chiasma frequency and localization is genetically controlled (Quick, 1993) and has been reported in several plant species as well as in crop plant varieties (Rees and Dale, 1974; Rees and Jones, 1977). Such variation between species and populations with the same chromosome number is considered to be a means for generating new forms of recombination which influences the variability within natural populations in an adaptive way (Rees and Dale, 1974).
When ANOVA was performed on the cytogenetic data for the n = 13 species no significant differences were found between species, indicating that these species are homogeneous for such characters. However, a significant difference in the number of ring and rod bivalents was observed among the n = 12 species and since the frequency and distribution of chiasmata was not significantly different in these species the significant difference observed in the number of bivalents may be due to fast terminalisation of chiasmata only. A joint analysis was performed for the n = 12 and n = 13 species using relative meiotic data but no significant difference was seen.
The UPGMA and WARD cluster analysis and principal component analysis (PCA) of the n = 12 and n = 13 (performed separately) species produced similar results, the UPGMA Euclidean distance clustering dendrogram and PCA ordination for the n = 12 species being presented in Figures 3 and 4. Two species (C. pterocaulos and C. crispa) appear to be very similar and are placed very close to each other in a single cluster, while two other species (C. pinarocephala and C. elbursensis) appear to be more distant.
Principal component analysis of the meiotic data for the n = 12 species revealed that the first two PCA factors accounted for about 99% of the total variance. The first factor accounted for about 81% of the total variance, with the mean number of ring bivalents, mean number of univalents, and total and terminal chiasmata having the highest positive correlation (>0.86). The second factor accounted for about 17% of the total variance, with the mean number of rod bivalents showing the highest positive correlation (>0.68). This analysis shows that these meiotic characters are the most variable among the n = 12 species, with the first factor characters separating C. elbursensis from the other species and the second factor characteristic separating C. crispa and C. pinarocephala from the other species (Figure 4).
The UPGMA dendrogram for the n = 13 species (Figure 5) shows three major clusters. The first major cluster contains 2 sub-clusters, one containing C. adenostegia and C. irritans and the other C. concolor and C. sheidaei which joining the first two species at some distance. The species C. discolor and C. hypoleuca are located a long way the first major cluster and each form a single cluster. Principal component analysis (Figure 6) of the n=13 species supports the cluster analysis showing separation of C. discolor and C. hypoleuca from the others and morphometric analysis of these species also produced similar results (unpublished data).
Principal component analysis of the meiotic data for the n = 13 species revealed that the first two PCA factors accounted for about 89% of the total variance. The first factor accounted for about 64% of the total variance, the highest positive correlation (>0.90) occurring with the mean number of ring bivalents and total and terminal chiasmata. For the second factor, Intercalary chiasmata showed the highest correlation (>0.70). These results show that these meiotic characters are the most variable among the n = 13 species, with the first factor characters separating C. elbursensis from the other species and the second factor characteristic separating C. discolor and C. hypoleuca from the other species (Figure 4).
The cluster and PCA analysis of the joint n = 12 and n = 13 species data are presented in Figures 7 and 8, from which it can be seen that the n = 12 and n = 13 species are placed in two different groups which reflect their distinctive in meiotic characteristics. This grouping could indicate the presence of specific genomic control in each group. Comparative morphometric, anatomical and pollen morphology studies carried out by us on these species showed similar results to those reported above (unpublished data). The n = 12 and 13 Cousinia species have also been shown to be distinct in terms of the DNA sequences of their ITS regions (Susana et al., 2003) which showed a close relationship between n = 11 species and n = 13 species while the n = 12 formed a different group.
Our data indicates that in order to understand the evolutionary patterns operating in the genus Cousinia further studies should be carried out on species with different chromosome numbers.
References
Afzal-Rafii Z (1980) Contribution a letude cytotaxonomique de quelques Cousinia de Iran. Biol Ecol Medit 7:9-14.
Attar F and Ghahreman A (2000) Two new species and a new record of the genus Cousinia Cass., Cynaroideae (Asteraceae) from Iran. Iran J Bot 8:259-269.
Attar F and Ghahreman A (2002) New taxa of genus of Cousinia. Iran J Bot 92:161-169.
Boissier E (1875) Flora Orientalis 3:463-466.
Ghaffari SM and Djavadi SB (1998) Chromosome studies and distribution of nine species of Cousinia section Stenocephalae (Asteraceae) in Iran. Bulletin de la Societe Neuchateloise des Sciences Naturelles 121:61-68.
Ghaffari SM, Attar F and Ghahreman A (2000) Distribution and chromosome studies on some species of Cousinia Cass. (section Cyanoideae) from Iran. Pakistan J Bot 32:311-316.
Ghahreman A, Iranshahr M and Attar F (1999).Introducing two and a rare species of the genus Cousinia Cass. Sect. Cynaroidae (Asteraceae). Iran J Bot 8:15-22.
John CK, Somani VJ and Thengane RJ (1989) Some interesting features of male meiosis in Chlorophytum tuberosum Baker. Current Science 58:254-255.
Podani J (2000) Introduction to the Exploration of Multivariate Biological Data. Backhuys Publisher, Leiden, pp 407.
Quick DLJ (1993) Principles and Techniques of Contemporary Taxonomy. Blackie Academic & Professional, Glasgow, pp 298.
Rechinger KH (1970) Flora Iranica. v. 90 (Cynerae), Akademische Druck-U. Verlagsanstalt, Graz, pp 87-95.
Rees H and Dale PJ (1974) Chiasma and variability in Lolium and Festuca populations. Chromosoma 47:335-351.
Rees H and Jones RN (1977) Chromosome Genetics. Edward Arnold, London, pp 160.
Sheidai M and Inamdar AC (1991) Variations in meiotic chromosomes in Asparagus L. Biovigyanum 17:45-47.
Sheidai M, Arman M and Zehzad B (2002) Chromosome pairing and B-chromosomes in some Aegilops species and populations of Iran. Caryologia 55:261-271.
Sheidai M, Noormohamadi M, Kashani N and Ahmadi M (2003) Cytogenetic study of some rapeseed (Brassica napus L.) cultivars and their hybrids. Caryologia 56:387-397.
Sokal RR and Rohlf FJ (1995) Biometry. 3rd dition. W.H. Freeman and Company, New York, pp 887.
Susana A, Garcia-Jacas N, Vilatersana R, Garnatje T, Valles J and Ghaffari SM (2003) New chromosome counts in the genus Cousinia and the related genus Schmalhausenia (Asteraceae, Cardueae). Bot J Linn Soci 143:411-418.
Sybenga J (1992) Cytogenetics in Plant Breeding. Spring-Verlag, Berlin, pp 469.(Masoud Sheidai; Kazem Meh)
IITehran University, Biology Department, Tehran, Iran
ABSTRACT
Meiotic studies of ploidy level, chromosome paring and chiasma frequency were performed on 11 Cousinia (Asteraceae) species of the section Serratuloideae. The diploid number of the species studied was 2n = 2x = 24 and 26 so these species possess two different basic numbers (x = 12 or 13), a phenomenon common to other sections of the genus. The chromosome numbers of 9 species are reported here for the first time. When the 2n = 24 and 2n = 26 species were subjected to cluster analysis based on relative meiotic characters two different clusters were formed indicating their distinctness. Our data support the results obtained from morphometry, anatomy, pollen morphology and molecular studies of the genus Cousinia.
Key words: Cousinia, chiasma frequency, cluster analysis, meiosis.
Introduction
The genus Cousinia (Asteraceae) is of worldwide distribution and comprises approximately 672 species, of which about 235 occur in central, western, eastern and southeastern Iran. According to Boissier (1875) the Serratuloideae section contains 9 species while Rechinger (1970) in Flora Iranica considers 11 species for this section.
Earlier reports on Iranian Cousinia are have been confined mainly to taxonomic studies (Ghahreman et al., 1999; Attar and Ghahreman, 2000; 2002) and a few chromosome number reports (Ghaffari and Djavadi, 1998; Ghaffari et al., 2000). Our study reported in this paper was the first cytological analysis of 11 Iranian species of the section Serratuloideae. We also discuss the cytological changes which play a role in the species diversification of this section.
Materials and Methods
Cytological studies were performed on 11 Cousinia species (Table 1), vouchers specimens are being deposited in the Herbarium of Tehran University (HTU), Iran.
For cytological studies young flower buds of each species were collected from at least 10 randomly selected plants and fixed in acetic acid: ethanol (1:3 v/v) for 24 h after which they were washed and preserved in ethanol at 4 °C until used (Sheidai et al., 2002). For each species, squash slides were prepared and stained with 2% (w/v) aqueous aceto-orcein and the chromosome numbers and chiasma frequency determined from 50 pollen mother cells at diakinesis-metaphase I (Sheidai et al., 2002). Due to insufficient number of meiotic cells, chiasma frequency and distribution was not analyzed in C. serratuloides.
In order to determine any significant difference in chiasma frequency and distribution among the species with either chromosome number (n) = 13 or n = 12 we performed analysis of variance (ANOVA) by the least significant differences (LSD) method (Sokal and Rolf, 1995; Sheidai et al., 2002).
Grouping the n = 12 and n = 13 species was performed using various cluster analysis methods including single linkage, unweighted paired group with arithmetic mean (UPGMA) and the WARD method as well as ordination based on principal component analysis (PCA) in each group separately (Podani, 2000; Sheidai et al., 2002). For numerical analyses meiotic characteristics such as chiasma frequency and distribution (terminal and intercalary chiasmata) and chromosomes association (ring and rod bivalents) as well as univalents were used.
For grouping both the species having n = 12 and 13, cluster analysis and PCA ordination was performed using relative meiotic characters (i.e. dividing the mean values of chiasma frequency and bivalents by the chromosome number to obtain meiotic values per chromosome) unaffected by the chromosome number (Sheidai et al., 2002). Euclidean distance was used for cluster analysis.
Results and Discussion
Variation in prophase sub-stages of meiosis-I
The meiotic analysis of the Cousinia species studied showed variation in the prophase sub-stages of meiosis-I (Figure 1, A-D). In the first sub-stage instead of the leptotene and zygotene stages a synezetic knot occurred consisting of thin chromatin strands surrounding the nucleolus and eventually totally covering it (Figure 1, A). Later, paired chromosomes unraveled from the knot and appeared as thick strands, ushering in the pachytene stage (Figure 1, B) of which end-to-end attachment of chromosomes is a feature reported in taxa showing a synezetic knot stage (John et al., 1989; Sheidai and Inamdar, 1991).
After pachytene, decompaction of the chromosomes occurs, commencing with the diffuse stage (Figure 1, C-D), which has been reported in several plant species (Sybenga, 1992), which may be complete with whole chromosomes undergoing decompaction or partial in which only part of the genome becomes decompacted. Our study showed an almost complete diffuse stage in the Cousinia species examined. Various reasons have been suggested for the occurrence of the diffuse stage, including high synthetic activity (i.e. the lampbrush stage in amphibian oocytes), shedding of the lateral elements of the synaptonemal complex, post pachytene elimination or modification of histone proteins and meiotic arrest to withstand adverse environmental conditions (John et al., 1989; Sheidai et al., 2003). We were not able to determine the exact reason for the occurrence of a diffuse stage in the Cousinia species studied by us but since these species grow in regions of Iran where the environmental conditions are harsh it may be an adaptation to these conditions. Unusual meiosis occurs in Cousinia species with different chromosome numbers, as has been reported in diploid and polyploid species of other plant groups (Sheidai and Inamdar, 1991) and the genomic control of the diffuse stage is not affected by ploidy level.
Chromosome number, chiasma frequency and distribution
Of the Cousinia species studied by us, elbursensis, pinarocephala, pterocaulos and crispa were n = 12 while adenostegia, concolor, hypoleuca irritans, sheidaei, discolor and serratuloides were n = 13 (Table 2, Figure 2). Except for C. crispa and C. hypoleuca this is the first time that chromosome numbers have been published for these species. In general, our study supports the chromosome number reported for C. hypoleuca by Afzal-Rafii (1980), although this author reported 2n = 26 for C. crispa as opposed to the n = 12 (2n = 24) which we recorded for this species. Our data shows that two different basic chromosome numbers (12 or 13) occur in the Serratuloideae section, a similar situation having been reported for other Cousinia sections including Cousinia and Leiocaules (both either n = 12 or 13) and Eriocousinia (n = 11 or 13, Susana et al., 2003). These data suggest aneuploidy, most probably by chromosome reduction during the evolution of the genus Cousinia (Susana et al., 2003).
Data on chiasma frequency and distribution as well as chromosome pairing is presented in Table 2. For the n = 12 species, C. elbursensis had the highest total number of chiasmata (17.00) and terminal chiasmata (16.90), while the highest number of intercalary chiasmata (0.70) occurred in C. pinarocephala and C. crispa. Among the n = 13 species the highest number of total and terminal chiasmata and ring bivalents occurred in C. discolor while the lowest values occurred in C. hypoleuca (Table 2). It is interesting to note that C. adenostegia, C. irritans and C. discolor did not form intercalary chiasmata but showed terminal chiasmata only (Table 2). Variation in chiasma frequency and localization is genetically controlled (Quick, 1993) and has been reported in several plant species as well as in crop plant varieties (Rees and Dale, 1974; Rees and Jones, 1977). Such variation between species and populations with the same chromosome number is considered to be a means for generating new forms of recombination which influences the variability within natural populations in an adaptive way (Rees and Dale, 1974).
When ANOVA was performed on the cytogenetic data for the n = 13 species no significant differences were found between species, indicating that these species are homogeneous for such characters. However, a significant difference in the number of ring and rod bivalents was observed among the n = 12 species and since the frequency and distribution of chiasmata was not significantly different in these species the significant difference observed in the number of bivalents may be due to fast terminalisation of chiasmata only. A joint analysis was performed for the n = 12 and n = 13 species using relative meiotic data but no significant difference was seen.
The UPGMA and WARD cluster analysis and principal component analysis (PCA) of the n = 12 and n = 13 (performed separately) species produced similar results, the UPGMA Euclidean distance clustering dendrogram and PCA ordination for the n = 12 species being presented in Figures 3 and 4. Two species (C. pterocaulos and C. crispa) appear to be very similar and are placed very close to each other in a single cluster, while two other species (C. pinarocephala and C. elbursensis) appear to be more distant.
Principal component analysis of the meiotic data for the n = 12 species revealed that the first two PCA factors accounted for about 99% of the total variance. The first factor accounted for about 81% of the total variance, with the mean number of ring bivalents, mean number of univalents, and total and terminal chiasmata having the highest positive correlation (>0.86). The second factor accounted for about 17% of the total variance, with the mean number of rod bivalents showing the highest positive correlation (>0.68). This analysis shows that these meiotic characters are the most variable among the n = 12 species, with the first factor characters separating C. elbursensis from the other species and the second factor characteristic separating C. crispa and C. pinarocephala from the other species (Figure 4).
The UPGMA dendrogram for the n = 13 species (Figure 5) shows three major clusters. The first major cluster contains 2 sub-clusters, one containing C. adenostegia and C. irritans and the other C. concolor and C. sheidaei which joining the first two species at some distance. The species C. discolor and C. hypoleuca are located a long way the first major cluster and each form a single cluster. Principal component analysis (Figure 6) of the n=13 species supports the cluster analysis showing separation of C. discolor and C. hypoleuca from the others and morphometric analysis of these species also produced similar results (unpublished data).
Principal component analysis of the meiotic data for the n = 13 species revealed that the first two PCA factors accounted for about 89% of the total variance. The first factor accounted for about 64% of the total variance, the highest positive correlation (>0.90) occurring with the mean number of ring bivalents and total and terminal chiasmata. For the second factor, Intercalary chiasmata showed the highest correlation (>0.70). These results show that these meiotic characters are the most variable among the n = 13 species, with the first factor characters separating C. elbursensis from the other species and the second factor characteristic separating C. discolor and C. hypoleuca from the other species (Figure 4).
The cluster and PCA analysis of the joint n = 12 and n = 13 species data are presented in Figures 7 and 8, from which it can be seen that the n = 12 and n = 13 species are placed in two different groups which reflect their distinctive in meiotic characteristics. This grouping could indicate the presence of specific genomic control in each group. Comparative morphometric, anatomical and pollen morphology studies carried out by us on these species showed similar results to those reported above (unpublished data). The n = 12 and 13 Cousinia species have also been shown to be distinct in terms of the DNA sequences of their ITS regions (Susana et al., 2003) which showed a close relationship between n = 11 species and n = 13 species while the n = 12 formed a different group.
Our data indicates that in order to understand the evolutionary patterns operating in the genus Cousinia further studies should be carried out on species with different chromosome numbers.
References
Afzal-Rafii Z (1980) Contribution a letude cytotaxonomique de quelques Cousinia de Iran. Biol Ecol Medit 7:9-14.
Attar F and Ghahreman A (2000) Two new species and a new record of the genus Cousinia Cass., Cynaroideae (Asteraceae) from Iran. Iran J Bot 8:259-269.
Attar F and Ghahreman A (2002) New taxa of genus of Cousinia. Iran J Bot 92:161-169.
Boissier E (1875) Flora Orientalis 3:463-466.
Ghaffari SM and Djavadi SB (1998) Chromosome studies and distribution of nine species of Cousinia section Stenocephalae (Asteraceae) in Iran. Bulletin de la Societe Neuchateloise des Sciences Naturelles 121:61-68.
Ghaffari SM, Attar F and Ghahreman A (2000) Distribution and chromosome studies on some species of Cousinia Cass. (section Cyanoideae) from Iran. Pakistan J Bot 32:311-316.
Ghahreman A, Iranshahr M and Attar F (1999).Introducing two and a rare species of the genus Cousinia Cass. Sect. Cynaroidae (Asteraceae). Iran J Bot 8:15-22.
John CK, Somani VJ and Thengane RJ (1989) Some interesting features of male meiosis in Chlorophytum tuberosum Baker. Current Science 58:254-255.
Podani J (2000) Introduction to the Exploration of Multivariate Biological Data. Backhuys Publisher, Leiden, pp 407.
Quick DLJ (1993) Principles and Techniques of Contemporary Taxonomy. Blackie Academic & Professional, Glasgow, pp 298.
Rechinger KH (1970) Flora Iranica. v. 90 (Cynerae), Akademische Druck-U. Verlagsanstalt, Graz, pp 87-95.
Rees H and Dale PJ (1974) Chiasma and variability in Lolium and Festuca populations. Chromosoma 47:335-351.
Rees H and Jones RN (1977) Chromosome Genetics. Edward Arnold, London, pp 160.
Sheidai M and Inamdar AC (1991) Variations in meiotic chromosomes in Asparagus L. Biovigyanum 17:45-47.
Sheidai M, Arman M and Zehzad B (2002) Chromosome pairing and B-chromosomes in some Aegilops species and populations of Iran. Caryologia 55:261-271.
Sheidai M, Noormohamadi M, Kashani N and Ahmadi M (2003) Cytogenetic study of some rapeseed (Brassica napus L.) cultivars and their hybrids. Caryologia 56:387-397.
Sokal RR and Rohlf FJ (1995) Biometry. 3rd dition. W.H. Freeman and Company, New York, pp 887.
Susana A, Garcia-Jacas N, Vilatersana R, Garnatje T, Valles J and Ghaffari SM (2003) New chromosome counts in the genus Cousinia and the related genus Schmalhausenia (Asteraceae, Cardueae). Bot J Linn Soci 143:411-418.
Sybenga J (1992) Cytogenetics in Plant Breeding. Spring-Verlag, Berlin, pp 469.(Masoud Sheidai; Kazem Meh)